Learn by asking
प्रश्नोत्तर
Questions the book itself asks are kept separate from study questions written from it. Every answer comes only from the source and points to the pages it is based on.
- Questions
- 294
- From the text
- 1
- Study questions
- 293
294 of 294 questions
Study questionWhen and where was the Kalyāṇakārakam first published, and how did the present edition come about?
It was first published at Solapur in 1940 by the Sakhārām Nemchand Granthamālā; the second edition was issued in August 2014 by Dharmoday Sahitya Prakashan, Sagar, at the inspiration of Āryikā Gurumatī Mātājī.
The publisher's note says the work had become rare and unobtainable. In 2003 Āryikā Gurumatī Mātājī's group, staying briefly in Solapur, asked about it; the editor's grandson Dr. Mahāvīr Śāstrī said the family could not get it reprinted, and with his consent Śrī Mahāvīr Luhāḍe of Jalna took on the reprint, which appears unchanged in its original form, in 1100 copies. The first edition had been published by Govindjī Rāvjī Dośī in memory of his father, Seṭh Rāvjī Sakhārām Dośī, who had worked for the recovery of the work.
Study questionHow is the Kalyāṇakāraka arranged, according to its front matter?
It has 25 chapters (pariccheda) and an appendix with the Riṣṭādhyāya, the Hitādhyāya and the Vanauṣadhiśabdādarśa, a glossary giving medicine names in Sanskrit, Hindi, Marathi and Kannada.
The introduction adds that for each disease the work treats the cause, prodromal signs, pathogenesis, treatment and curability together, sets out rasa, rasāyana and kalpa preparations in separate chapters, and has a section on fatal signs. Rai Bahadur Narasiṁhācārya, quoted by the editor, says the work opens by dividing medicine into prevention and cure and ends with a long Sanskrit prose discourse on the uselessness of a flesh diet.
Study questionWhich manuscripts did the editor use to establish the text?
Four: a copy of the palm-leaf manuscript in the Mysore Government Library, a palm-leaf manuscript in Kannada script from Shravanabelagola, a Mumbai copy that seems to be made from it, and an old, mostly correct paper manuscript from Raichur district.
The editor says the Mysore copy is handsomely written but incorrect and omits the Hitāhitādhyāya, while the Raichur manuscript resolved many difficulties; its colophon traces its copying from Bālacandra Bhaṭṭāraka (Śaka 1351). He collated the copies, noted variant readings in places, and printed the Hitāhitādhyāya, found in two copies, as it stood because it was too corrupt to correct.
Study questionWho prepared the 1940 edition, and who made it possible?
Pt. Vardhamān Pārśvanāth Śāstrī edited and translated it; Pt. Anantarājendra Śāstrī of Mumbai and Pt. Bindumādhav Śāstrī of Ahmednagar revised it; Vaidya Pañcānana Pt. Gaṅgādhar Gopāl Guṇe Śāstrī wrote the introduction; and Seṭh Rāvjī Sakhārām Dośī inspired and supported the work.
The editor says Dośī had the first copy made at the Mysore Government Library, encouraged the translation, supported the founding of the Kalyāṇa press named after the work, and gathered materials and funds; he died before the book appeared, and his son Seṭh Govindjī Rāvjī completed the task and published it in his memory. The editor, who says he is not a physician, signed his statement at Solapur on 1-2-1940.
Study questionWhat is the Prāṇāvāya, and how is the Kalyāṇakāraka related to it?
In the Jain canon the Prāṇāvāya is one of the fourteen Pūrvas of the twelfth aṅga, the scripture that sets out the eight-limbed Ayurveda; Ugrāditya says he composed the Kalyāṇakāraka in Sanskrit by condensing this Ardhamāgadhī scripture.
The editor says the Jain āgama is authoritative because the gaṇadharas arranged the Omniscient's divine voice into the twelve aṅgas, and that the Prāṇāvāya also deals with poisonous creatures and their treatment and the division of prāṇa and apāna; citing chapter 25, verse 54, he regards the Kalyāṇakāraka as part of that canon. The introduction's footnote, calling it the Prāṇavāda Pūrva, says all ācāryas composed their Ayurvedic works in accordance with it.
Study questionWhat two purposes of medicine and what two kinds of health does the editor report from the work?
Medicine protects the health of the healthy and frees the sick from disease (chapter 1, verse 24). Health is ultimate (pāramārthika), the imperishable bliss of the soul, or practical (vyāvahārika), the balance of the dhātus, agni and doṣas with clear senses, a joyful mind and a disease-free body.
The editor says medicine is composed to benefit the world and that the work treats both purposes in brief. Ultimate health is said to come from destroying the eight karmas; the author names the karma that brings pain (asātāvedanīya) as the main cause of ill health and doṣa imbalance as its outer cause.
Study questionWhat does the front matter say about wine, meat and honey in the Kalyāṇakāraka?
No formula in the work uses wine, meat or honey, because they arise from violence; and its last section, which Ugrāditya is said to have delivered at the court of Nṛpatuṅga Vallabha, sets out to prove that meat is of no use in medicine.
The introduction says giving them up upholds non-violence and that they are not indispensable in treatment. The editor reads Somanātha's Kannada verse as showing that Pūjyapāda's Kalyāṇakāraka also used no wine, meat or honey, and cites K. Śeṣaśāstrī, Kavirāj Gaṇanāth Sen and Kavirāj Yogīndranāth Sen as physicians who rejected wine and meat in medicine. He argues that plant medicines can remove even terrible diseases, citing Samantabhadra's bhasmaka disease.
Study questionWhen did Ugrādityācārya live, according to the editor, and on what evidence?
He was a contemporary of the Rāṣṭrakūṭa king Amoghavarṣa I (Nṛpatuṅga), living in the 8th century of the Śaka era, the 9th century of the Vikrama and Christian eras.
The work cites earlier ācāryas presumed to be before the sixth century, and its closing sentence says Ugrāditya delivered its last section in the assembly of Nṛpatuṅga Vallabha; the editor identifies this king with Amoghavarṣa I, whose accession historians place in Śaka 736 (815 CE) and who was a disciple of Jinasena. He cites Prof. Saletore and Rai Bahadur Narasiṁhācārya, who calls Ugrāditya a contemporary of Amoghavarṣa I and of the Eastern Cālukya king Kali Viṣṇuvardhana V. The earlier introduction by Gaṅgādhar Guṇe Śāstrī infers only that the work is later than Vāgbhaṭa.
Study questionWhere was the Kalyāṇakāraka composed, and who was Ugrāditya's guru?
In the Jina temple on the Rāmagiri hill in Veṅgi, the chief place of the Trikaliṅga country; his guru was Śrīnandi Ācārya.
The editor says Ugrāditya's brief self-introduction in chapter 25 names Śrīnandi, whose feet a king called Śrī Viṣṇurāja Parameśvara worshipped. He explains Trikaliṅga as North Kaliṅga or Utkala (from the Gaṅgā to Kaṭaka), Middle Kaliṅga (from Kaṭaka to Mahendragiri) and South Kaliṅga (from Mahendragiri to the Godāvarī), and suggests the Rāmagiri may be the one where, according to the Padmapurāṇa, Rāmacandra had temples built.
Study questionWhich earlier Jain medical authors and works does the editor discuss?
Chiefly Pūjyapāda (a Kalyāṇakāraka, a Śālākyatantra and the Vaidyāmṛta), Samantabhadra (the Siddhānta Rasāyana Kalpa), the sages of the Puṣpāyurveda, Gummaṭadeva Muni (Merutantra) and Siddha Nāgārjuna (Nāgārjuna Kalpa, Nāgārjuna Kakṣapuṭa), as well as authors who wrote medical works in Kannada.
He notes that Ugrāditya cites the views of earlier ācāryas such as Pūjyapāda, Samantabhadra, Pātrasvāmī, Siddhasena, Daśarathaguru and Meghanātha, whose works are now lost. He says Samantabhadra's work had 18,000 verses, that the Puṣpāyurveda gives rasāyana preparations from 18,000 kinds of pollen-free flowers, and that Somanātha's Kannada translation of Pūjyapāda's Kalyāṇakāraka is the oldest medical work in Kannada, and he laments that such works are being lost to insects.
Question from the textLord of the three worlds, for us who are afflicted by cold, heat and rain, have taken to wrong food, do not know the proper order of diet and medicine and suffer from the fear of many diseases, what is the way to remove disease and to protect health? Please tell us.
The Lord's divine voice answered by setting out, in brief, the four subjects of the whole science (the person, diseases, medicines and time) with their features, kinds and sub-kinds.
Bharata and others put the question in the assembly of Ṛṣabhanātha, explaining that in the present land of action many humans have lives that can be cut short and live in great fear from the aggravation of vāta, pitta and kapha (verses 4-6). After they fell silent, the divine voice went forth (verse 7) and first described the person, diseases, medicines and the distinctions of time, dividing the whole of Ayurveda into four subjects (verse 8). This teaching was received by the gaṇadharas and handed down through the sages (verses 9-10), and the book states the purpose of the science as protecting the health of the healthy and freeing the sick from disease (verse 24).
Study questionWhat are the four pillars (pādas) of treatment in the Kalyāṇakāraka, and which of them is the chief?
The physician, the patient, the medicine and the attendants; the wise physician is the chief.
Verse 28 says that what the sages call kriyā is treatment and that it rests on four components endowed with their qualities: the physician, the patient, the medicine and the attendants who serve the patient. The commentary adds that the wise physician is the chief, because without him the other three are useless.
Study questionHow does the commentary explain the word Ayurveda, and what twofold purpose does the text give for medical science?
'Veda', from the root vid (knowledge, reflection, gain), means what reveals the true nature of things, and joined with 'āyus' it names the science of life. Its purpose is to protect the health of the healthy and to free the sick from disease.
Verse 19 and its commentary say the science is called Ayurveda because it sets out wholesome and unwholesome, happy and unhappy life, the signs and measure of life span and the substances good or bad for life. Verse 24 says the science exists to benefit the world and has two aims: protecting the health of the healthy and releasing the sick from disease.
Study questionAccording to chapter 1, what should the physician ascertain before starting treatment, and by what means?
The patient's span of life, learnt through questions, portents, omens, scripture, astrology, dreams and the words of those with divine knowledge.
Verse 30 tells the physician to learn the measure of the patient's life through questions, portents, omens, scripture, astrology (ascendant and lunar conjunctions), dreams and divine statements before making efforts at treatment. Verse 31 adds that no one dies without death signs (riṣṭa), which must be searched for carefully, and verses 33-37 describe the messenger's signs and the omens met on the way that point to the patient's death.
Study questionWhat two kinds of health does chapter 2 describe, and what are the marks of practical health?
Ultimate (pāramārthika) health, the bliss of liberation, which is primary, and practical (vyavahāra) health, which is secondary; practical health means balanced digestive fire and tissues, undisturbed doshas, proper elimination of wastes and a clear self, senses and mind.
Verse 2 says the Jinas declared health to be of two kinds, the first and chief being ultimate health and the other arising from worldly practice. Verse 3 describes ultimate health as the wondrous, final, unequalled bliss beyond the senses born of the destruction of all karmas. Verse 4 lists the marks of practical health: balanced fire and tissues, absence of dosha disturbance, proper excretion and constant clarity of self, senses and mind; a footnote quotes Vāgbhaṭa's similar definition. Verse 7 adds simply that one whose body is free of disease is called healthy.
Study questionWhich states of the digestive fire does chapter 2 describe, how are they defined, and which procedures does the text pair with the disordered ones?
Balanced fire digests a proper meal properly; irregular fire (from vāta) sometimes digests it and sometimes not; sharp fire (from pitta) digests even an excessive meal; weak fire (from kapha) cannot digest even a small one. The text pairs enema therapy, purgation, and emesis with nasal therapy with the vāta, pitta and kapha types in that order.
Verse 11 asks the physician to judge whether a person's fire is balanced, irregular or weak; verse 12 says disordered fire is threefold, irregular from vāta, sharp from pitta and weak from kapha, and its footnotes give the definitions. Verse 13 pairs enema, purgation and emesis with nasal therapy with these in order, and verse 14 says balanced fire is protected by seasonal food and by enemas, purgation and emesis suited to the three periods; a footnote defines balanced fire. These are purification procedures that the text assigns to the physician.
Study questionHow does the text distinguish the three kinds of land, and which disorders and treatment does it associate with each?
Dry land (jāṅgala), with thin, rough-bodied people, mostly has vāta disorders and calls for vāta-pacifying treatment; marshy land (ānūpa), with stout, kapha-predominant people, has vāta disorders with much kapha and calls for treating kapha and vāta; ordinary land (sādhāraṇa) has balanced conditions, no dosha disturbance and is the best.
Verse 19 names the three lands and calls the ordinary one chief. Verses 20-24 describe dry land by its rough vegetation, hard hills, scarce deep wells and thin people with prominent veins, who suffer mostly from vāta. Verses 25-34 describe marshy land by its cold water, mud, lush trees, lakes and rich milk-and-jaggery diet, whose stout people suffer vāta disorders with much kapha. Verses 35-38 describe ordinary land as free of extremes, where seasonal food and balanced fire keep the doshas undisturbed so that disease does not arise.
Study questionAccording to chapter 2, how does the embryo develop in the womb, and how is it nourished?
It becomes kalala in ten days, turbid in ten more and firm in ten more, then bubble-like and solid in the following months; flesh grows in the fifth month, limbs in the sixth, skin, nails and hair in the seventh, and the head's opening pulsates in the eighth; birth comes in the ninth or tenth month. Until the seventh month it absorbs juices from the mother's food all around; after that it feeds through a navel cord.
Verse 48 says the semen mixes with the woman's blood in the womb and the soul enters by its karma; verses 51-52 say the joined mass gains the six capacities within an antarmuhūrta and takes bodily form. Verses 53-54 give the timeline, adding that if the child is not born within ten months a disorder is to be understood. Verses 55-57 say the child lies wrapped in the jarāyu between stomach, intestine and rectum, drinks the pitta- and kapha-rich juices formed from the mother's food like a corpse in a water pot, and after seven months receives nourishment through a lotus-stalk-like navel cord that the commentary connects to the mother's heart; birth may go well or end in the death of the child or even the mother.
Study questionWhat counts of bones, joints, sinews, veins, muscles, vessels and vital points does chapter 3 give, and what does the editor's footnote say about the joints?
300 bones, 300 joints, 900 sinews, 700 veins, 500 muscles, 24 vessels (dhamanī) and 107 vital points. The footnote says the joint count cannot equal the bone count, notes Suśruta's 300 bones and 210 joints, and calls the reading a scribal error.
Verse 2 counts 300 bones, 300 joints, 900 sinews, 700 veins and 500 muscles; the footnote argues that two bones meet at one joint, so joints must be fewer, cites Suśruta (300 bones, 210 joints) and, although all three manuscripts read the same, judges the reading corrupt. Verse 3 counts 24 dhamanīs from the navel (ten up, ten down, four crosswise), 16 kaṇḍarās and 6 kūrcas. Verse 4 adds 2 muscle cords, 7 skin layers, 8 channels, one liver, one spleen and 16 rows of large intestine. Verse 5 gives 107 vital points, 9 openings and eighty lakh hair pores, and verse 6 gives 32 teeth and 20 nails.
Study questionHow does chapter 3 explain the origin of constitution (prakṛti), and what are some marks of the vāta, pitta and kapha types?
Constitution is formed by the dosha that predominates when the soul enters the mixed semen and blood in the womb, and it is balanced if all three are equal. The vāta type is described as thin and rough, with dry sparse hair and cracked feet, restless and wakeful; the pitta type as quick-tempered, sharp-witted, sweating and warm-bodied, ageing and balding early; the kapha type as stout, steady, patient and fond of sweets, with a deep voice.
Verse 17 and its commentary say the dominant dosha at the moment the soul enters the mixed semen and blood decides the constitution: a pitta-dominant mass gives a pitta constitution, and so on, with equal doshas giving a balanced one. Verses 18-20 describe the vāta type as disliking cold, wakeful and talkative, unsteady and friendless, thin and rough with cracked feet and visible vessels, dreaming of mountain peaks and the sky. Verses 21-24 describe the pitta type as angry, intelligent, eloquent and skilled, with red lips and palate and a warm, loose body, ageing early, balding, always hungry and dreaming of gold, fire and red flowers. Verses 25-27 describe the kapha type as intelligent, stout and cheerful, grateful, prosperous, with a voice like a drum or lion, tolerant of pleasure and pain, slow to learn but accomplished, dreaming of lotus pools and rivers.
Study questionFrom which eight animals does the text describe urine, and what properties does it give them?
Cow, goat, buffalo, horse, donkey, camel, elephant and ram; all are said to kill worms, to be pungent, bitter, hot, dry and light, and to remove kapha and vata.
Verse 35 opens the group of urines (mūtravarga) with eight kinds of urine and gives them one shared set of properties: they destroy worms, are pungent, bitter and hot, dry and light, and remove kapha and vata.
Study questionWhat is alkali (kṣāra) said to overcome, and what warning does the text give about it?
Kushtha, tumours, nodules, kilāsa, painful urination, piles, corrupted wounds and all worm diseases; by its fiery power it burns the body.
Verse 36 says alkali always shares the properties of urine. The commentary lists the conditions it conquers and adds that its fiery (āgneya) power burns the body. The text gives no preparation or dose here.
Study questionWhat after-drink does the text give for every kind of food in general?
Warm water, drunk after the meal.
Verse 39 calls warm water drunk afterwards the one medicine for all food in general. The same verse names sauvīra for bitter foods and sour buttermilk for salty foods, and the commentary adds that taking kāñjī with the meal is good.
Study questionWhich after-drink goes with astringent fruits and vegetables, and which with sweet foods?
A sweet after-drink with astringent fruits and tuber and leaf vegetables, and a pungent one with plainly sweet foods.
Verse 40 calls a sweet after-drink wholesome with astringent fruits and tuber and leaf vegetables, and an after-drink of pungent substances best with foods that are plainly sweet. A footnote glosses katu as covering both pungent and bitter.
Study questionWhat after-drinks are named for sour and for pungent foods, and which drink suits every taste?
A salty after-drink for sour foods and a bitter and astringent one for pungent foods; milk is wholesome with every taste.
Verse 41 gives the salty after-drink for sour foods, bitter and astringent after-drinks for pungent foods, and calls milk a wholesome after-drink with all tastes.
Study questionHow should the physician choose an after-drink, according to the conclusion of the section on after-drinks?
By giving whatever the person craves, is wholesome for them and suits their constitution.
Verse 42 notes that cravings shift: heavy use of sour can bring a longing for sweet, and overuse of another taste a longing for sour. The physician should therefore apply, by the rule of after-drinks, whatever is wholesome, appetizing and suitable for each person.
Study questionWhat does the text advise doing with the hands right after a meal, and what is it said to achieve?
Wash the hands, rub them together, touch the eyes with the wet hands and rub the face lightly; this is said to help the eyes and make the face radiant.
Verse 43 says the eyes gain brightness and various eye diseases go away, and that the face, rubbed this way every day, becomes radiant like a lotus while facial vyanga, tilakālaka, nīlī and other conditions are removed.
Study questionWhat sequence of conduct does verse 44 lay down after eating?
Rinse the mouth, take astringent, bitter and pungent things or a pleasant smoke to clear kapha, sit at ease, walk a hundred steps, lie briefly on the left side, avoid exercise and sit a while taking liquids.
The commentary names areca nut, catechu, clove, musk and betel as the astringent, bitter and pungent things, and explains that kapha increases as soon as one eats. A footnote adds: after eating, sit like a king.
Study questionAccording to the commentary on the closing verse of chapter 5, why is the book called Kalyāṇakāraka?
Because it is the one benefactor of the world.
Verse 45 likens the work to a drop drawn from the ocean of scripture that came from the mouth of the Jina, whose waves are all substances and principles and whose two shores are the means to the aims of this world and the next; the commentary concludes that it is therefore named Kalyāṇakāraka.
Study questionIn what liquid and quantity is chandramrita taken, and at what time?
Mixed in one kudava of breast milk (16 tola in the commentary), drunk in the morning.
Verse 58 says to take a kudava of breast milk and drink it in the morning; the commentary says the person sits alone in the inner chamber of the specially built house, away from relatives and attendants, mixes the chandramrita into 16 tola of breast milk and drinks it with a steady mind.
Study questionHow do the leaves of chandramrita change through the lunar month?
They grow daily in the bright fortnight and are full at full moon, then decline in the dark fortnight and all fall on the new-moon day.
The text says the plant waxes and wanes with its leaves like the moon. The commentary adds that it is very hard to find and grows in lakes, deep rivers and mountain regions, and that its potency, name and form are one and many like the Jain syadvada, that is, beyond conception.
Study questionWhat kind of house is prepared for the chandramrita regimen?
A very solid house with three walls and three storeys that is entered only after three circumambulations; the user stays alone in its central chamber.
Verse 58 and its commentary describe the house and say the user sits in its inner chamber (garbhagriha), separated from relatives and attendants, to drink the chandramrita.
Study questionWhat is given to eat after the emesis and purgation in the chandramrita regimen?
At first only milk, fragrant and boiled then cooled; once strength appears, shali rice with ghee and milk once a day, along with massage, bath and anointing.
Verses 59-60 say that the person who has been properly vomited and purged, lying on the ground and hungry, is given only milk by the attendants, daily and very cool; after the strength born of the nectar is seen, bath, massage and anointing follow, and a meal of shali rice with milk and ghee is given once a day.
Study questionHow does the user of chandramrita return to the outside world after a month?
Wearing shoes, socks, a warm coat and a turban and accompanied by family, he goes out at night and gets used to fire, wind, cold, heat and drinking water, then returns to the house, daily.
Verse 61 says that after a month, with feet covered, body wrapped and head covered, protected and surrounded by attendants, he leaves his dwelling night after night, practises exposure to fire, wind, cold, sun and water, and again lives in the house in the same way.
Study questionTo whom should chandramrita and the other divine medicines not be given?
To the sinful, timid, careless, those without family or wealth, those who disrespect medicine, lack aspiration or enthusiasm, are given to vices or unrestrained, the angry, those hostile to the Jina's teaching and wicked people.
Verse 65 describes these medicines as the source of prosperity and happiness and lists the people who must be excluded from receiving them.
Study questionWhy do even rich people fail to obtain the great divine medicines?
Because of fate, ignorance, lack of money, unavailability of the drug, an unsteady mind, lack of steady effort, their nature, lack of a suitable house, contact with unfriendly relatives and friends, or unbelief.
Verse 66 says that even the generous and wealthy do not obtain these great medicines, though they are most beneficial to them, for these reasons.
Study questionHow does the text describe kapha diarrhoea (shleshmatisara)?
The stool is white, thick and very cold and comes slowly and in large amount; the patient feels chilled and the body heavy and cold.
Verse 86 and its commentary attribute these signs to an excess of kapha and call the disease shleshmatisara. The following verse adds the signs of sannipata, ama and pakva diarrhoea.
Study questionHow does the text tell ama diarrhoea from pakva diarrhoea?
Stool that sinks in water and smells foul marks ama diarrhoea; the opposite signs mark pakva diarrhoea.
Verse 87 gives this test. Verse 90 asks the physician to judge the ama and pakva states before treating; the commentary explains digestion (pachana) for ama and binding (stambhana) for pakva.
Study questionWhich diarrhoea patients does the text call very hard to treat and to be given up?
The very young, the very old, the emaciated, the weak and the consumptive, and those whose stool looks like ghee, spleen, fat, liver, oil, water, milk, curd or buttermilk.
Verse 89 gives this list. Verse 88 adds that diarrhoea from excessive grief, with very bloody hot stool, bloating, colic, complications such as thirst, swelling, fever, breathlessness and cough, loss of appetite and a weakened voice, is said to destroy the patient.
Study questionWhat emesis does the text describe for diarrhoea with much ama, and what follows it?
Warm water mixed with a paste of madanaphala, rock salt and long pepper is drunk to induce vomiting; nothing is eaten that day, and the next day a little warm vilepi or yusha cooked with binding drugs is given.
Verse 90 prescribes the emesis and verse 91 the after-care, given once intoxication, burning and the doshas have settled. Both records are marked as requiring professional supervision.
Study questionFor which stage of diarrhoea is Amrasthyadi powder given, and with what?
For diarrhoea in the pakva stage; it is drunk with whey.
Verse 95 lists mango seed kernel, lodhra, liquorice, sesame, padmaka, dhataki flowers, silk-cotton gum, bael pulp, priyangu, kutaja bark, ativisha and manjishtha, powdered together.
Study questionHow is the Tvagadi putapaka juice made and taken?
Barks of cinnamon, aralu, kutaja, mango, kadamba and jambu are ground with thick rice water, wrapped in banana leaves, cooked by putapaka and squeezed; the cooled red juice is drunk with liquorice paste.
Verses 96-97 say the juice is fragrant and red and overcomes diarrhoea very quickly. As an alternative, ambashthika, pomegranate and tinduka cooked in buttermilk are drunk.
Study questionHow is Jambvadi phanitaka prepared and taken?
A decoction of jambu, mango, neem, musta, aragvadha and dhataki flowers is reduced to one eighth, strained and cooked until it coats the ladle; the thick preparation is licked.
Verse 98 says licking it overcomes diarrhoea soon; the commentary calls the product an avaleha.
Study questionIn which diseases does the text call lukewarm milk wholesome?
Long-standing diarrhoea, chronic fever, insanity, epilepsy, urinary stone, gulma, abdominal enlargement, liver disorder, vata, breathlessness and cough, spleen enlargement, ashthila, urinary gravel, asrigdara, burning, vertigo, depleted semen and fainting.
Verse 101 names cow's milk taken lukewarm and adds that milk prepared with medicines suited to each disease is better still.
Study questionWhich foods does the text call wholesome in long-standing diarrhoea and chronic fever?
Buttermilk with rock salt and dry ginger; mung soup with cumin tempered with ghee, salt and black pepper; and milk prepared with ajamoda and rock salt.
Verse 102 lists these three as wholesome food for people with chronic diarrhoea and chronic fever.
Study questionAccording to chapter 10, how should a physician deal with curable, manageable and incurable diseases?
Cure the curable with medicines, keep the manageable in check with skilled procedures, and declare the incurable as incurable and give them up.
Verse 27 says curable (sadhya) diseases are to be cured with medicines and other measures, manageable (yapya) diseases are to be sustained with various procedures, and diseases that are hard to understand and hard to treat are incurable; the physician should say so and abandon them.
Study questionWhat does the text advise when not all the medicines of a group can be obtained?
Treat with half of them, or half of that, or with as many as are available.
Verse 26 calls the medicine groups unique and unfailing and says that if the whole group is not available, using half, half of that, or finally whatever can be obtained still makes the diseases subside.
Study questionWhat should the physician weigh before treating, according to the chikitsa sutra verse of chapter 10?
The dosha that caused the disease, which dosha is strong or weak, the merits and faults of the medicines, and the signs of the major diseases.
Verse 25 describes the learned physician as one who considers which dosha produced the disease and which is strong or weak, understands the good and bad qualities of excellent medicines, knows the signs of the major diseases, and then conquers diseases with suitable medicines.
Study questionWhy does the author say the medicines in the text are not complete?
Substances and their tastes, potencies, post-digestive effects and specific actions are countless and cannot all be told in a short treatise.
In verse 24 the author says many more medicines with greater and wonderful qualities exist beyond those described; even all-knowing physicians leave the account of substances incomplete, so someone like himself cannot complete it.
Study questionBy what name is Tvagadi churna known in practice, according to the footnote?
Sitopaladi churna.
Footnote 1 on PDF 227, attached to the heading of the Tvagadi powder (verse 22), says that in practice it is called Sitopaladi churna.
Study questionHow does the closing verse of chapter 10 describe the treatise, and why is it called Kalyanakaraka?
As a drop from the ocean of scripture that came from the Jina's mouth; the commentary says it is the one benefactor of the world, hence the name.
Verse 28 pictures an ocean whose waves are all substances and whose two banks are the means for this world and the next; the treatise is a drop from it. The commentary adds in brackets that because it is the sole benefactor of the world it is named Kalyanakaraka.
Study questionWhich aspects of the doshas does verse 23 tell the physician to attend to when treating?
Their types, sub-types, mixed forms, and greater or lesser predominance.
After the causes, signs and remedies of the three doshas have been told in brief, the physician is to pacify diseases by applying fitting medicines with attention to the types, sub-types, combinations and predominance of the doshas.
Study questionAccording to chapter 7, what is the main cause of disease?
One's own karma done before; all other causes are secondary.
Verse 11 says every disorder has a cause, to be sorted into primary and secondary: the primary cause is one's own past karma and the rest are its instrumental qualifiers. Verse 13 adds that diseases arise not from the anger of the elements, aggravation of the doshas, a bad year or the planets, but from the rise and udīraṇā of karma, while verse 10 names the aggravation and calming of the doshas as the instrumental causes through which sin and merit bear fruit.
Study questionInto which two kinds does the text divide treatment, and what does external treatment consist of?
Internal treatment, which is dharma, and external treatment, which is only an auxiliary cause; external treatment means oleation, sudation, emesis, purgation and, where suitable, excision and incision, chosen according to substance, place, time and condition.
Verse 30 calls dharma the internal cause of calming disease and external treatment an auxiliary cause, which is what the book describes. Verse 31 says that by following dravya, kṣetra, kāla and bhāva and applying oleation, sudation, emesis and purgation, or excision and incision in diseases that need them, the sick person becomes well. Earlier, verse 14 says the wise call the practice that calms karma, such as worship and meditation, the real treatment.
Study questionIn what two ways are aggravated doshas said to ripen?
By means (upāyapāka), through medicines that remove the unripe state of the disease, and by time (kālapāka), on their own without medicine.
Verse 16 compares the doshas to fruit, which ripens on the tree by itself or is ripened by skilled people. Verse 17 defines ripening by means as ripening the doshas with medicines that remove āma, and ripening by time as their ripening within their own period without medicine, which is seen in animals, birds and the destitute. The same two ways of ripening are described for karma in verses 14-15.
Study questionWhat makes a physician fit to treat, according to this chapter?
He must know both the texts and the practice, and be truthful, steady, forgiving, light-handed, healthy, experienced and careful; one who knows only theory or only practice is not fit.
Verse 38 lists the physician's qualities: truthful, steady, forgiving, light-handed, accomplished and healthy, having seen great treatments, having learned the whole science from a teacher, and free of carelessness. Verses 46-48 add that he must study under a teacher and also gain practical experience; two half-physicians together are as useless as two one-legged men tied together, and only one skilled in both, who knows medicines, instruments, surgical instruments and texts, may treat the people with the king's permission. Verses 49-51 say an ignorant physician kills, should be stopped by kings, and turns even good medicines into dangers.
Study questionWhat are the four limbs of treatment and what qualities should the attendant have?
Physician, patient, medicine and attendant; the attendant should be strong, forgiving, steady, devoted to helping others, tolerant, affectionate and skilful.
Verse 42 says that physician, patient, medicine and attendant, each with its qualities, are the four unequalled limbs of treatment, and together they destroy disease quickly, as a king defeats enemies with his fourfold army. The patient should be wealthy, long-lived, intelligent, well supported by family and servants, strong, self-controlled and wish for his own good (verse 39); the medicine should come from a good region, be gathered in season, small in dose, pleasant, of good appearance, taste and smell and work as soon as taken (verse 40); and the attendant has the qualities of verse 41. Verse 43 adds that the physician, helped by the other three, brings quick relief.
Study questionBy which three means is the patient examined, and what is learned by touch?
By seeing, touching and questioning; touch shows whether the body is hot or cold, hard or soft, unctuous or dry, light, heavy or clear, and whether this is natural or deranged.
Verses 52-53 tell the physician to learn the strength of the disease and whether it is curable by seeing, touching and questioning before treating. By touch (verse 54) he judges heat, cold, hardness, softness, oiliness, dryness, lightness, heaviness and clarity of the body affected by the doshas, the commentary adding the movement of the pulse. By questions (verse 55) he learns the patient's region, family, natural state, digestive fire, the force of the disease, strength, desired food, stool and urine and what suits him. By sight (verse 56) he reads shade, form, marks, signs and temperament to judge whether life span is declining or growing.
Study questionHow does the text classify diseases by curability?
Into curable and incurable; the curable are hard to cure or easy to cure, the incurable are manageable (yāpya) or untreatable (anupakrama), four kinds in all.
Verse 58, which names Samantabhadra as its source, divides diseases into curable and incurable, each in two kinds. Hard-to-cure diseases yield only to great effort, arrangements and formulations, easy ones to little effort, short time and few medicines (verse 60). Manageable diseases are held down by suitable medicine and diet but kill in time, while untreatable ones take life at once; before treating such incurable states the physician should say so clearly, or he earns disrepute (verse 59). Verse 61 sums these up as four kinds.
Study questionWhat does the text say happens when treatment is delayed or not done properly?
Each disease slides one class worse: easy becomes hard, hard becomes manageable, manageable becomes untreatable, and the untreatable kills at once.
Verse 62, which the commentary attributes to Ācārya Pūjyapāda, says that without prompt treatment by the method of the texts, curable diseases become hard to cure, hard ones manageable, manageable ones untreatable, and untreatable ones destroy life immediately. Diseases destroy precious life as quickly as fire or a snake, so they should always be set right promptly with proper treatment. Verse 57 similarly warns that a great disease may look slight and a slight one incurable, so the physician should weigh everything by reasoning and scripture and treat quickly.
Study questionWhy does the text say the soul must be understood through syādvāda for treatment to be possible?
Because if the soul were wholly permanent no treatment would be needed, and if wholly momentary there would be no one to treat.
Verses 3-6 describe the soul as knower and seer, bound to a body made by its own karma, the doer and enjoyer of its karma, the size of its body, and permanent yet changing through birth, old age and death. Verses 7-8 say only a physician whose doctrine holds this view can give treatment that brings happiness, because absolute permanence or absolute momentariness would rule treatment out; so the syādvāda (anekānta) view must be adopted. Verse 9 extends this to the person, disease, medicine and time, which are to be held valid only in a relative sense.
Study questionHow should the patient's house and bed be arranged?
The house should be in an auspicious place, protected, clean, guarded and stocked with medicines; the bed new, wide and curtained, with the patient lying head to the east or south.
Verses 18-21 describe the house first because it matters most: built in an auspicious direction and place, protected by mantra, yantra and tantra rites, always swept, lit, scented with incense and hung with flowers, guarded and entered only by tested men and women, not draughty or full of holes or defects, and stocked with equipment and good medicines. Verses 22-23 give a good cot with new, wide, pleasing bedding, curtains all round and a canopy above; steady, alert and calm friends and relatives watch over the patient, who lies with the head to the east or south.
Study questionWhich diseases does the Kalyanakarakam call the major diseases (mahamaya)?
Prameha, kushtha, udara, vatavyadhi, mudhagarbha, haemorrhoids, urinary stone and fistula-in-ano.
Verse 4 of chapter 11 says the omniscient ones call these the major diseases. The chapter then undertakes to describe each with its signs, fatal signs, curability, chief causes, prevention and treatment, and begins with prameha.
Study questionWhat causes prameha according to the text, and what are its prodromal signs?
Too much heavy, liquid, unctuous and cold food, much day sleep, lack of exertion and idleness; the prodromes are burning in the hands, feet and body, thirst, an unctuous sticky body, sweetness in the mouth and overeating.
Verse 6 gives the causes and verse 7 the prodromes. Verse 8 explains that the aggravated doshas with fat reach the bladder and ripen there, so that turbid urine flows copiously and often, which the commentary calls the chief sign of prameha.
Study questionWhat does the commentary say happens if prameha is not treated quickly?
It turns in time into madhumeha; the patient is then called madhumehi and develops prameha boils.
The commentary on verse 10 adds this to the definition of prameha (passing much urine with the prodromes present). Verse 43 says that when the patient is not treated with the diet, conduct and medicines described, the boils appear especially on the lower body, and verse 44 notes that the madhumeha patient is hard to purge.
Study questionWhich ten boils (pidaka) are said to occur in prameha patients, and how are they treated?
Sharavika, sarshapika, jalini, putrini, kacchapika, masurika, vidarika, vidradhika, alaji and vinata; they are treated with leeches and strong purgation, ripening applications, incision, cleansing and healing.
Verse 11 names nine and calls them ten; the commentary adds vinata, which verses 19-20 describe. Each is named after its form, for example sharavika after a shallow earthen dish and masurika after a lentil, and all arise from the three doshas. Verses 44-46 give leech bloodletting and strong purgation, then pressing, plastering and bandaging with mustard, radish seed, rock salt, drumstick and the three pungents until the boils ripen, then incision, cleansing and healing.
Study questionHow are thin and stout prameha patients treated differently, and what is the general course of treatment?
The thin are built up with nourishing medicines and the stout are made lean with reducing (karshana) measures.
Verse 29 says prameha patients are of these two kinds by birth or through unwholesome diet. The course that follows is a dry diet that avoids alcohol, milk, ghee, sour things, sweets, curd, sugarcane and meat; oleation with sesame, linseed and mustard oil and emesis with neem juice and madanaphala; purgation; a niruha enema with cow urine and sesame oil; and grains and pulses such as kodo millet, barley, wheat and green gram.
Study questionWhat kinds of exertion does the text prescribe for prameha patients?
Constant exertion such as riding elephants and horses, weapon practice and running; a poor well-born patient is sent on pilgrimage on foot, and a poor patient of low birth digs wells and tanks and tends cattle.
Verse 40 calls for constant practice of exertion to remove prameha. Verse 41 sends a well-born but poor patient whose disease is hard to cure on pilgrimage on foot, and verse 42 tells a poor patient of low birth to dig wells, tanks and step-wells, tend cows, eat once a day what he gets by begging and drink water of the kind cows drink.
Study questionHow is the wound dressed and bandaged after a prameha boil has been opened?
The wound is cleansed with cleansing drugs, filled with a healing paste, covered with leaves and wrapped in fine cloth; the next day the bandage is opened, the pus pressed out, the wound washed with decoction water, dressed and bandaged again.
Verses 47-48 list the cleansing drugs (karanja, turmeric, neem, kutki and others) and the healing drugs (sesame, lodhra, liquorice, arjuna bark, manjishtha and others). Verses 51-53 describe the bandage and say that bandaging cleanses the wound, heals it and makes it soft and painless, so it is the right course in all wounds. A clean wound is stable, without pus, painless, pigeon-coloured and fleshy; a healed one is level with the skin and of the same colour (verse 55).
Study questionBy what signs is a prameha patient known to be free of the disease, and when is he called incurable?
He is free when he passes urine that is clear, very bitter, dry, alkaline, slightly warm and not turbid, only now and then and in small amounts.
Verse 56 gives these signs of recovery. In contrast, verses 25-27 describe as incurable the patient whose urine flows like fat, ghee, honey or an elephant's rut fluid, who has the complications, boils on vital places, dreams of swimming in or drinking from rivers and seas, and a wasted body; treating such a patient is called futile.
Study questionWhat are the seven great kushthas and from which doshas do they arise?
Aruna from vata; kapala, rishyajihva, audumbara and kakanaka from pitta; dadru and pundarika from kapha.
Verses 61-62 say these are called great because they penetrate the tissues and are mostly incurable. Minor kushtha has thousands of varieties through kapha and blood (verse 63); the text goes on to describe sidhma, rakasha, mahakushtha, eka, vicharchi, vipadika, parisarpa, visarpana, kitibha, charmadala, pama and kacchu, and verse 58 says kushtha takes eighteen forms.
Study questionWhich kushthas does the text treat as curable, manageable or incurable?
Kushtha in the skin, blood and flesh is curable with medicines; in the fat it is only manageable; the rest, in bone, marrow and semen, does not heal even with panchakarma.
Verses 76 and 84 give this scheme. Also incurable are kilasa, tridoshic kushtha, non-discharging pale kushtha in the skin and congenital kushtha (verse 70), pundarika like a white lotus and kakanaka coloured like the bandhuka flower, gold or the bimba fruit (verse 77), and a badly affected child of parents with kushtha (verse 78). Severe eye disease, loss of voice and pus flowing from the sores are the fatal signs (verse 78).
Study questionHow often are emesis, purgation, bloodletting and head purgation done for a kushtha patient?
Emesis every fifteen days, strong purgation every month, bloodletting every six days and head purgation every three days.
Verse 99 says kushtha patients must be purified upward and downward and bled freely, because remaining dosha makes the kushtha return. Verses 100-101 then give the schedule and call it the course of treatment for all kushtha, to be carried out by a careful physician.
Study questionWhich pastes are given after the shvitra verse to restore normal skin colour?
The bhallataka-seed paste (verse 97) and the bhallatakadi paste (verse 98), both made with burnt drugs in sesame oil.
Verse 96 says the kushtha pastes also apply to shvitra and announces colour-restoring pastes. The first uses bhallataka seed, chitraka, bilva pulp, bhringaraja, arka latex, orpiment and realgar, or the hides of leopard, tiger, elephant or deer; the second burns bhallataka, the three myrobalans, arka latex, sesame, the three pungents, vidanga, apamarga, kanjira, bitter gourds and neem seed.
Study questionHow is the pot prepared for the fermented kushtha preparations?
A ghee pot is heated in fire, leaves of jambu, kapittha, tulasi, mango and citron are boiled in it, it is washed with fragrant water, smeared inside with pepper and pippali in sugar water, perfumed with flowers and bound outside with cords.
After the medicine, jaggery and khadira decoction are put in, the mouth is sealed and the pot is buried in a pit filled with grain. The text says every such nectar-like preparation (every arishta, in the commentary) is made this way; the danti and iron preparation is taken out after seven days, fifteen days or a month, and the ash-water preparation after a month.
Study questionWhat diet and total amount go with the sharp iron ash, and what result is claimed for it?
Food free of salt and sour things, and one tula in all (5 ser in the commentary); one who does so is said to live a hundred years free of disease.
Verses 119-121 describe making the ash with sixteen heatings and taking it with ghee and sugar after judging strength, saying it removes kushtha, spleen disease, piles and pandu and gives strength, youthfulness and comfort. Verse 122 adds the diet and the one-tula course, and the commentary concludes that it is a rasayana.
Study questionWhat is navayasa made of and which diseases is it said to relieve?
Musta, vidanga, triphala, chitraka and the three pungents with an equal amount of iron, taken with sugar and ghee; it is said to relieve pandu, prameha, piles, severe kushtha, sinuses and worm disease.
Verse 123 has the nine drug parts powdered with iron equal to them; the commentary says nine parts of iron bhasma and leaves out triphala. Verse 124 calls it the well-known navayasa and lists the diseases it relieves when used by the proper method.
Study questionWhat eight kinds of udara does the commentary list?
Vatodara, pittodara, kaphodara, sannipatodara (dushyodara), yakrit-plihodara, baddhagudodara, kshatodara (parisravi udara) and dakodara.
Verse 127 says terrible mahodaras arise from the doshas singly or together, liver and spleen disorders, water, poisoning, and obstruction or foreign bodies. The commentary explains these causes, including drinking water during oleation and similar procedures and a foreign body lodged in the intestine, and derives the eight kinds from them.
Study questionHow do baddhagudodara and sravi udara arise?
Baddhagudodara arises when hair, small stones or grass in food lodge in the intestine; sravi udara when a thorn or sharp object swallowed unknowingly pierces the intestine.
In baddhagudodara faeces accumulate in the intestine and pass with great difficulty, with a foul faecal smell (verse 134). In sravi udara much watery fluid oozes from the pierced intestine and passes through the anus, with pricking pain (verse 135).
Study questionWhich udaras does the text call curable by medicines, which by surgery, and which incurable?
The first four (vata, pitta, kapha and combined) by medicines and the other four by surgery, with both needed after a long time; udaras that have ended as jalodara, and patients who refill quickly after purgation with anorexia, broken-feeling flanks and swelling, are to be left as incurable.
Verse 139 says that at the final stage all udaras become jalodara and incurable (in old age, the commentary says) and adds baddhodara and sravi udara to those the physician should avoid; verse 140 (printed 141) calls the rest difficult to cure with daily skilled care; verse 141 divides the eight between medicine and surgery; verse 142 gives the signs of incurability.
Study questionHow is naracha ghee prepared, and how long is it taken?
Cow milk four times the snuhi latex is boiled with it, set into curd with buttermilk and churned; the butter is cooked again with snuhi latex. It is drunk for half a month or a month.
Verses 158-159 call it the best of ghees and the means against the great diseases; the commentary says it works through purgation and is the one excellent means against kushtha, udara and similar great diseases, and that ghees made with decoctions of purgative drugs also help. Verses 160-161 cook it again with more purgative drugs to make mahanaracha ghee.
Study questionWhy is the fluid in jalodara drained only a little at a time, and how long does the draining take?
Because draining it all at once may bring on severe thirst, intense fainting, fever and burning; the fluid is let out from the left side over fifteen days, with the waist cloth tightened as it drains.
Verse 174 prepares the patient with oil, a lukewarm bath and a waist cloth and punctures the stated place with an edgeless instrument; verses 176-177 drain the fluid through a two-mouthed tube a little at a time; verse 178 then keeps the patient on food taken with lukewarm milk for six months.
Study questionWhat are the four kinds of sudation described in chapter 12, and which suit vata joined with kapha?
Heat (tapa), binding (upanaha), steam (ushma) and liquid (drava); heat, binding and steam sudation suit vata joined with kapha.
Verse 6 lists the four kinds. Vata joined with kapha is sweated with heat, binding and steam, while vata joined with blood and pitta is given liquid sudation with milk, water, ghee and kanji. The commentary describes each: heated sand bundles or bricks, a thick poultice bound with leaves, steam from heated iron, a decoction pot with a tube or an ember pit, and immersion in or affusion with warm decoction.
Study questionHow is head basti (shirobasti) performed according to the commentary?
A leather sleeve open at both ends is fixed on the head, sealed with black gram paste, filled with vata-reducing oil and held for a thousand kshana.
For vata in the head, the cap-like sleeve of leather or thick leather-like cloth is set on the head, its join sealed with black gram paste and filled with vata-reducing oil; the head is kept still for a thousand kshana until discharge begins from the nose, mouth and eyes, and the sleeve is then removed.
Study questionWhich signs mark hemiplegia (pakshaghata) as incurable in chapter 12?
A swollen and numb body, distension, a bent and trembling body, excessive vata, absence of pain and wasted limbs.
Verse 33 says a hemiplegia patient with these signs, gripped by excessive vata and without pain, is to be regarded as incurable and given up.
Study questionHow does the footnote on earache treatment define one matra of time?
As the time taken to circle the knee once with the hand and snap the fingers.
Verse 44 has the ear filled with medicated oil or with goat urine, garlic and arka juice and held for a hundred, five hundred or a thousand matra; the footnote explains that one matra is the time of one circle of the hand round the knee and a snap of the fingers.
Study questionHow do the footnotes distinguish garbhasrava from garbhapata?
Garbhasrava is the loss of the fetus in the first four months; garbhapata is its loss in the fifth or sixth month.
Verse 46 gives the causes of a fallen pregnancy (riding, much walking, slipping, intercourse, falls and blows) and verse 47 describes the young fetus up to four months, when excited vata causes distension, pain, retention of urine and heavy bleeding; the footnotes on PDF 275 fix the two terms by month.
Study questionWhat must the physician do before and during the extraction of an obstructed fetus?
Explain the difficulty to the king and the relatives, cut his nails, smear the hand with slippery drugs and ghee, and take care not to harm mother or fetus.
Verses 54-56 call the extraction very hard. The physician informs the king and the woman's relatives, inserts a nail-trimmed hand smeared with slippery drugs and ghee, and draws the fetus out compassionately by pulling it as it lies, turning it, sliding it or pulling at once as its position requires; the verse adds that mantras are recited.
Study questionWhich treatments does chapter 12 forbid for children's diseases?
Cautery, purgation, caustic alkali, surgery, emesis and the like; mild measures are used instead.
Verse 82 says children's diseases are not to be treated with these harsh measures and that curable diseases are treated with suitably mild ones; verse 81 adds that children receive the same medicines as adults by dosha, with the dose fitted to age, strength and dosha.
Study questionWhat are the six kinds of piles named in chapter 12?
Vataja, pittaja, kaphaja, raktaja, sannipataja and sahaja (congenital).
Verse 85 lists the six. Vataja piles are hard with pain, distension and retention of flatus and stool; pittaja and raktaja are soft and bleed very hot blood; kaphaja are very hard, large and itchy; sannipataja show all signs together; sahaja are very minute with the signs of sannipataja, and all are called hard to cure.
Study questionAccording to the commentary, which piles are treated with medicine, which with alkali, which with cautery and which with the knife?
Recent, mild, internal piles with medicine; soft, spread, thick, raised ones with alkali; rough, firm, raised, hard ones with cautery; thin-based, hanging, moist ones with the knife.
After the procedure for removing piles, the commentary on PDF 287 sorts piles by their character to choose the treatment; verses 112-113 add that vata and kapha piles take alkali and cautery, blood and pitta piles alkali, thick-based hard large piles excision and cautery, and soft piles in a strong patient pastes and drug combinations.
Study questionWhy are piles called mularoga, the root disease?
Because they give rise to many other diseases, being their root cause.
Verse 90 says piles produce nodules, gulma, liver enlargement, ashthila, abdominal disease, loss of strength and colic; because they are the root of so many diseases they are called mularoga or mulavyadhi.
Study questionHow does the text explain the formation of urinary gravel (sharkara)?
Kapha entering the bladder with urine settles like mud in a new pot, is dried hard by heat and is broken by vata into sand-like grains.
Verse 3 compares it to mud forming by itself at the bottom of a new pot of clear water. Verse 4 adds that strong vata breaks the dried kapha into two, three or many pieces, which lodge in the urinary passage and cause severe pain in the waist, groin, bladder and penis; a footnote says a stone broken up by vata is called sharkara.
Study questionWhat are the four kinds of ashmari, and which dosha does the text find in all of them?
Kaphaja, pittaja, vataja and shukraja (from semen); kapha predominates in every stone.
Verse 6 names the four by primary and secondary factor. A footnote explains that even a pitta stone has kapha at its root, because a dense stone-like mass cannot form from the other doshas without kapha.
Study questionWhy does the text say a stone in a child is easy to remove?
Because the child's body and bladder are small, its flesh is scant and an instrument can be applied easily.
Verse 13 says stones are especially common in children, from much day sleep, a very narrow urinary passage, rich sweet food and naturally abundant kapha; verse 14 then explains why removal is easy.
Study questionWhen does the text say a urinary stone yields to medicine, and when does it call for surgery?
A soft stone is cured by medicines; a hard, grown stone is broken open with care and removed, that is, by surgery.
Verse 19 likens ashmari to thunderbolt, poison, fire and a snake. Verse 17 calls a stone with terrible pain, bloody urine passed with difficulty and ulcers incurable or hard to cure, and verse 18 says a patient with swollen navel and scrotum, blocked urine and extreme pain is to be given up.
Study questionHow long is the uttara basti nozzle for men, women and girls?
Eight, four and two finger-breadths, measured by the patient's own finger.
The men's nozzle is round, smooth, made of silver or another metal, with a collar at its base and shaped like a jasmine stalk; the women's has a large collar and the girls' a collar too. All are fitted to a bag, and the fluid given is at most one prasrita.
Study questionWhat are the five kinds of bhagandara, and which are called incurable?
Shatayonaka (vata), ushtragala (pitta), parisravi (kapha), kambukavarta (all three doshas) and unmargi (foreign body); the all-dosha and foreign-body kinds are incurable.
Verse 49 says all kinds are by nature very hard to cure and that the sannipata and shalyaja kinds should be left alone. A footnote defines bhagandara as a very painful boil within two finger-breadths of the anus that bursts there.
Study questionWhy must the surgeon avoid making a large wound in bhagandara?
Through a large wound faeces, urine and semen escape and the tract worsens; the anus can be torn, and wind escaping from it causes colic and distension.
Verses 56-59 also say that joined tracts are cut at once and separate ones in turn after each heals, and that the incision is shaped like a half-plough (ardhalangala) or a cow's trail (gotirtha).
Study questionWhat should a bhagandara patient avoid after the wound heals, and for how long?
For two months: sexual intercourse, long journeys, much riding, wrestling and other causes of injury, and food that makes the stool hard.
Verse 70 and its commentary also ask the patient to keep a proper regimen of food and evacuation during these two months.
Study questionInto how many kinds is scrotal enlargement (vriddhi) divided, and which kind is to be declared incurable?
Seven, from vata, pitta, kapha, blood, fat, urine and intestine; the intestinal kind (antravriddhi) is to be declared incurable before treatment.
For the urine type the scrotum is pierced with the vrihimukha instrument and drained through a tube as in jalodara; for the fat type it is opened avoiding the sevani and the fat removed; for antravriddhi, once declared incurable, bala oil or castor oil with rock salt is given with vata-reducing care.
Study questionHow does the text say upadamsha should be treated?
With the dosha-based treatment sequence given earlier for the kinds of scrotal enlargement.
Verse 2 applies the scrotal-enlargement treatments to upadamsha according to the dosha and to all other severe swellings; a tooth-caused case gets cold ghee, milk and very cooling pastes (verse 6).
Study questionWhat causes shuka disease according to verse 8?
Rubbing the penis with rough, uneven leaves to enlarge it, masturbation and intercourse with a narrow vagina.
These produce many eruptions on the penis; the text prescribes ghee affusion and sudation, and a footnote says the disease has eighteen kinds.
Study questionWhich drugs make up the trikatukadi poultice for shlipada, and how is it applied?
Trikatu, garlic, asafoetida, vacha, ingudi and langali, applied daily as a paste with warm leaves bound over it.
The text says this calms aggravated shlipada, but a shlipada that has grown excessively is to be regarded as incurable.
Study questionHow does the text explain the name apachi?
Fat accumulates (upachaya) at the jaw, throat, eyes and joints and forms small hard swellings, so it is called apachi.
Its nodules may burst and discharge, subside by themselves or keep appearing anew; treatment aims at kapha and fat with emesis, strong nasal medication and purgation.
Study questionHow are the unripe, ripening and ripe stages of a swelling told apart?
Unripe is hard; ripening has fever, much burning and warmth; ripe has lost its severe pain and changed colour.
A hot-group poultice comes first, which makes an unripe swelling subside or ripen quickly; a ripe swelling is cleansed by incision with a sharp knife.
Study questionWhat are the eight surgical acts listed in verses 30 and 31?
Excision, incision, scraping, puncturing, probing, extraction, draining and suturing.
The verse likens them to the eight kinds of karma of embodied beings, and names the heron-beak instrument (kankavaktra) for extracting foreign bodies; footnotes define each act.
Study questionIn vidradhi, which direction of pus discharge does the text call fatal and which curable?
Pus coming out upward, with breathlessness, cough, hiccup and other vata signs, is fatal; pus draining downward is curable.
Verse 26 adds that a vidradhi ripened in the anus, heart, liver, navel, spleen or bladder is not curable.
Study questionHow should minor diseases that the text does not describe be treated?
Since no disease arises without the doshas, decide from the signs which dosha is primary and which secondary and treat with suitable pacifying drugs.
The text adds that describing them again would be grinding what is already ground (pishtapeshana).
Study questionWhat does the text advise for a jatumani birthmark?
An auspicious jatumani is left untreated; an inauspicious one is removed with drugs and other means.
Jatumani is described as a round, red, painless mark present from birth, from kapha and blood, called lahsan in the vernacular.
Study questionWhat prognosis does the text give for agnirohini?
It is to be left untreated; the patient lives fifteen days at most.
The verse says it ends within a fortnight; it arises from all doshas at the trika, neck, hands, flanks and feet with burning like a forest fire.
Study questionWhich ten kinds of head disease does chapter 15 describe?
Those from vata, pitta, kapha, blood and all doshas together, plus suryavarta, ardhavabhedaka, shankhaka, the worm-caused type and the depletion type.
Verse 3 names head diseases from vata, kapha, blood, pitta and all doshas together, and suryavarta, ardhavabhedaka and shankhaka; verse 4 adds the worm-caused and depletion types, and verse 10 closes the section by counting ten. Verse 8 directs treatment by the dominant dosha with venesection, head purgation, heating, binding, mouthfuls and plasters.
Study questionHow does the text tell suryavarta from ardhavabhedaka?
Suryavarta pain rises from morning to midday with the sun and wanes as the sun goes down; ardhavabhedaka is severe pain in exactly one half of the head.
Both are described in verse 5. Verse 7 adds that head pain from blood and pitta is worse by day, and pain from vata and kapha worse at night.
Study questionWhat does the footnote on shankhaka add about its course?
It adds severe burning and swelling at the temple and a choking of the throat as under the force of poison, and says the disease kills within three days.
Verse 6 describes shankhaka as vata, alone or with kapha, pitta and blood, causing pain especially at the temples on cold, windy and cloudy days; the footnote on the same page gives the further signs and the three-day course.
Study questionHow is dipika oil prepared according to the footnote on verse 24?
A stick of bilva, shyonaka, patala, gambhari or agnimantha (one or all five) is wrapped in cloth over three parts, soaked in oil and lit like a wick held tip down; the oil dripping into a vessel below is dipika oil.
The footnote gives the stick as eighteen angula long and says oil can be drawn the same way from devadaru, kushtha and sarala wood. Verse 24 has the ear washed with a decoction of trivrit, turmeric, aragvadha and kutaja and then filled with dipika oil, which is said to destroy worms and severe pain.
Study questionHow is foreign matter lodged in the ear removed, and by whom?
If the patient is strong, a physician skilled in suction carefully draws it out with an applied gourd or horn, or removes it with a probe; an insect that has entered the ear is removed the same way.
This is verse 25 with its commentary; the text stresses the patient's strength, the physician's skill in suction and great care.
Study questionHow many diseases does this part of chapter 15 count for the ear, nose, teeth, gums and throat?
Twenty-eight of the ear, thirty-one of the nose, eight of the teeth, fifteen of the tooth roots (gums) and seventeen of the throat; five tongue diseases and nine palate diseases are also announced.
The counts come from verse 27 (ear), verse 43 (nose), verse 50 (teeth), the commentary on verse 65 (gums), the commentary on verse 79 (throat), the commentary on verse 59 (tongue) and the heading before verse 95 (palate). The mouth is said to have seven sites of disease (verse 44).
Study questionWhat does the text advise for a worm-eaten tooth (krimidanta)?
The wise physician should extract it quickly; the commentary adds that drugs cannot cure it.
Krimidanta is described as a tooth with black holes, very loose, discharging pus without special cause and always aching (verse 51). Verse 79 refers back to the krimidanta measures for khalavardhana, where the extra tooth is extracted and its root burnt.
Study questionWhich throat diseases does the text say are to be given up as incurable or deadly?
Rohini of the combined, kapha and blood types (in the commentary), adhijihvika once suppurated, valaya, mahalasa, vrinda and shataghni are to be given up; galavidradhi and mamsatana are also described as deadly.
Curable rohini is treated with bloodletting, mouthfuls, smoking, emesis, licks, head purgation and rubbing, while kanthashaluka, ekavrinda and gilayu are incised; throat diseases in general are treated with emesis, nasal drops, plasters and gargles (verse 94).
Study questionWhat diet does the text call wholesome in nasal diseases?
Meals of ghee, milk, rice pudding (payasa) and moistening foods, together with nasal medication and drugs chosen for the strongest dosha.
Verse 40 gives this regimen; verse 41 adds head purgation, head saturation, medicated smoke, gargles, licks and khala cooked with pungent, hot and alkaline substances for all nasal diseases.
Study questionWhich four diseases affect the whole mouth, and why is sarvasara so called?
Vichari and the vata, pitta and kapha types of sarvasara; sarvasara is so called because it spreads to seven places of the mouth.
Verse 103 names one separate disease, vichari, and sarvasara arising from the three doshas. A footnote explains that sarvasara spreads to the mouth, tongue, throat, lips, gums, teeth and palate. Vichari, a pitta swelling with burning, foul smell and high fever, is later listed among the incurable diseases.
Study questionHow many mouth diseases does the text describe, and how many are to be abandoned as incurable?
Sixty-six mouth diseases are described, of which nineteen are to be abandoned.
The nineteen are three lip diseases (from the three doshas, flesh and blood), two of the tooth roots, three of the teeth, alasa of the tongue, arbuda of the palate, eight of the throat (svaraghna, valaya, vrinda, mahalasa, mamsachaya, rohini, galaugha, shataghni) and vichari of the whole mouth.
Study questionWhat goes into Bhringarajadi oil and how is it used?
Bhringaraja juice, amalaki juice and sesame oil, one prastha each, four prastha of cow's milk and a pala of liquorice paste; it is given as nasal drops for many mouth diseases.
The commentary gives one prastha as 64 tola and the liquorice as 16 tola, used as paste. All are combined and the oil is cooked until done; the text says its nasya destroys many diseases of the mouth.
Study questionWhat are the seats of eye diseases and how many of each are there?
Five circles (mandala), six junctions (sandhi) and six layers (patala).
The circles are lashes, lids, white, black and sight; four junctions lie between them, with the fifth at the inner corner and the sixth at the outer corner. Two layers are in the lids and four in the eyeball, and timira arises in those four layers.
Study questionHow does the editorial note explain tarpana and putapaka?
Tarpana is holding eye-beneficial juices or ghee in the eyes of the patient lying on his back; putapaka is juice squeezed from a leaf-wrapped, clay-coated ball of drugs roasted in a cow-dung fire and put into the eyes like tarpana.
The note follows verse 133 on vata-type abhishyanda. It names mango and similar leaves for wrapping and says the clay and leaves are removed before the ball is squeezed.
Study questionWhat follows if abhishyanda is neglected, and how quickly does untreated adhimantha destroy sight?
It turns into adhimantha of the same dosha; untreated, the kapha type destroys sight in seven days, the vata type in six, the blood type in five or three, and the pitta type at once.
Adhimantha is marked by tearing, churning eye pain and severe pain in half the head. The text urges quick treatment with suitable medicines and those of abhishyanda, and says neglected vata-type adhimantha becomes the incurable hatadhimantha.
Study questionWhich nine diseases arise in the junctions of the eye?
Parvani, alaji, puyalasa, kaphopanaha, four kinds of discharge (kapha, pitta, blood and pus) and krimigranthi.
The footnote to verse 171 equates the pus discharge with the sannipata type. Alaji is a hard, black, painful knot from kapha; when it ripens and discharges pus it is puyalasa; krimigranthi is a very itchy knot made by worms at the junction of lid and white.
Study questionWhat food and drink does the text give in pitta-type abhishyanda?
Gruel cooked in milk with ghee and sugar, green gram soup, rice pudding with ghee or rice with green gram soup, cooling vegetables, and scented water in measured amounts.
The vegetables are cooked and of astringent, bitter and sweet taste with cooling potency. For thirst the water is made pleasant with sandalwood scent and perfumed with fragrant flowers and camphor.
Study questionHow many eye diseases does the text count, and how are they divided by cause?
Seventy-six: ten from vata, ten from pitta, thirteen from kapha, sixteen from blood, twenty-five from all three doshas and two from external causes.
Verse 230 gives ten diseases for each dosha with three more for kapha, sixteen for blood, twenty-five for the combination of all three doshas and two external ones, and verse 231 totals them as seventy-six. The following verses sort each group into curable, palliable and incurable diseases.
Study questionHow does the text describe drishti, the seeing part of the eye?
As a round, lentil-sized part suited to coolness, arising where the karma that veils the eye-sense is subsided and destroyed; it perishes quickly and must be protected with great care.
Verse 209 and its commentary describe drishti in Jain terms as arising where the karma that covers the faculty of sight is partly destroyed and partly subsided (kshayopashama). It is round like a lentil, favours coolness and is the part through which forms are seen. Because it is easily destroyed, it is to be guarded with great effort.
Study questionHow does sight change as the doshas move through the layers of the eye?
In the first layer things are seen indistinctly; in the second even a needle's eye cannot be seen; in the third things below are not seen and objects look like hair, mosquitoes or flies; in the fourth, timira blocks sight completely and is called linganasha.
Verses 211 to 215 describe these stages. A small amount of kapha lodged in the first three layers is said to cause night blindness (naktandhya), while timira reaching the fourth layer is linganasha, which has six kinds.
Study questionWhich eye diseases does the text say should be excised?
Eleven: the five kinds of arma, sirajapidaka, sirajala, arbuda, shushkarsha, arsho vartma and parvani.
Verse 245 divides the seventy-six eye diseases by treatment: eleven to be excised, five incised, nine scraped, fifteen punctured, twelve treated with medicines only, seven palliable and fifteen to be given up. Verse 246 names the eleven to be excised. The text presents these as procedures for a trained physician.
Study questionHow does the text describe the needling procedure for kapha-born linganasha?
After the kapha type is recognised by pressing, the patient looks at his nose and the physician slowly pierces the natural opening in the white of the eye with a smooth copper yavavaktra probe, makes him sneeze to expel kapha, withdraws the probe once objects are seen, and then gives nasya.
Verses 279 to 281 say that a linganasha which disperses on pressing is born of intense kapha. The patient is asked to look towards his own nose; the physician considers the white region and pierces the natural opening gradually with the very smooth copper probe called yavavaktra, makes the patient sneeze to bring out the kapha, and withdraws the probe slowly when objects in front become visible. The patient then lies on his back and is given nasya with pungent, dry, kapha-removing drugs. The text presents this as an operation by a physician.
Study questionWith what is triphala powder taken in linganasha of each dosha?
With sesame oil in the vata type, with ghee in the kapha type, and with white sugar in the pitta and blood types.
Verse 284 and its commentary say that triphala powder taken in this way gives the eyes clarity, nourishment and excellence. The verse speaks of timira in the kapha case, and the commentary calls all of them linganasha.
Study questionWhat does the text give for amladhyushita, and where is one of these remedies said to be unsuitable?
Eye drops of palasha gum with milk and sugar, and a triphala decoction with ghee to drink; the triphala remedy is said not to be beneficial in shukti.
Verses 258 and 259 first say that all pitta-born eye diseases are treated with cooling measures. The palasha gum drops are said to remove the pitta eye diseases and amladhyushita quickly, and the triphala decoction mixed with ghee is drunk for amladhyushita, with the remark that it does not suit shukti.
Study questionWhat advice for protecting sight does the text attribute to Samantabhadra?
To refrain from constantly reading tiny letters and from gazing at bright lamps and intense light.
Verse 291 calls this restraint the protection of one's sight, which is perishable by nature. The preceding verse names other famous measures for the eyes: foot massage taught by Pujyapada, cold nasya and collyrium of Siddhasena, and tarpana of the eyes and head of Jatacharya.
Study questionHow does the text treat an injured eye?
If the eye has not left its place, ghee is smeared and a bandage bound; if it is ruptured and hanging, it is separated and treated by the wound procedure, with sudation, plasters, smoking, nasya and nourishing therapy.
Verses 253 and 254 distinguish an injured eye that stays in place from one that is ruptured. The second case refers back to the wound treatment described earlier in the book and is work for a trained practitioner.
Study questionWhat are the five kinds of shvasa and which of them are curable?
Maha, urdhva, chhinna, tamaka and kshudra; kshudra and tamaka are curable, the rest are to be abandoned.
Kshudra shvasa arises on slight exertion and settles on rest; tamaka comes in a weak person with kapha and cough and worsens on eating. Tamaka is very hard to cure in a very weak person, and the sages say the other three kinds should be abandoned.
Study questionHow does the text treat a strong and a weak shvasa patient differently?
The strong patient first gets emesis and then oil enema and other purifications; the weak patient gets pacifying medicines only.
Verse 9 says purification is planned for strong patients, beginning with emesis followed by oil enema and other cleansing; for weak patients only pacifying medicines are used. Remedies that follow include Pippalyadi ghee, Bharangyadi powder, Bhringaraja oil and Tvagadi powder.
Study questionWhat are the five kinds of cough, and which one does the text call hard to treat?
Vataja, pittaja, kaphaja, kshataja and kshayaja; kshayaja cough is tridoshic and hard to treat.
Kshataja cough follows chest injury from exertion such as study and brings thick bloody discharge. Kshayaja cough comes in a person weakened by tissue loss who spits blood-red sputum. For injury and wasting cough the text gives a powder of amalaki, gokshura, dates, priyala, liquorice, blue lotus, bharangi and long pepper with ghee and sugar on a milk diet.
Study questionWhy is thirst arising from ama treated like pitta thirst?
Because the text says thirst cannot arise without pitta.
Verse 34 says ama thirst, counted among the dosha kinds, is treated with the whole course for pitta thirst. A footnote describes it as thirst from indigestion of food with heart pain, salivation and malaise, and explains that including it under the dosha kinds keeps the count of five.
Study questionWhich signs make a case of vomiting incurable according to the text?
Vomit mixed with blood, pus and kapha, constant complications and repeated fainting.
Verse 41 says a physician who knows the matter should leave such a patient as incurable. For curable vomiting with strong doshas, verse 42 calls for emesis and purgation with dosha-destroying drugs.
Study questionHow many kinds of svarabheda are described, and which are called incurable?
Six (vata, pitta, kapha, tridoshic, fat and blood); the tridoshic and blood kinds are called incurable.
Causes named include loud recitation, grief, poison, a blow to the throat and loud speaking. Fat-born hoarseness is treated like the kapha kind, and the incurable kinds are attempted only after careful thought. Daily ghee after meals is given for the vata kind, milk with ghee and jaggery for pitta, and alkaline water with the three pungents and three fruits for kapha.
Study questionWhat does the text say about holding back natural urges?
Those who want a long life should never hold back an urge; doing so causes udavarta.
Holding back urges makes provoked apana rise into udana. The text names seven kinds by the urge held back (flatus, urine, faeces, semen, vomiting, tears, sneezing), each with its own effects, and says all are treated with the treatment for vata disorders; neglected udavarta is said to kill quickly.
Study questionWhat are the five kinds of hikka and what produces them?
Annaja, yamika, kshudrika, mahapralaya and gambhirika, produced by the vayu called prana provoked with kapha.
Annaja follows excess sharp and pungent food; yamika comes in pairs shaking head and throat; kshudrika comes slowly from the root of the collarbone; mahapralaya shakes the whole body and afflicts the vital points; gambhirika rises from the navel with a deep sound and complications such as fever.
Study questionHow does the text treat new coryza compared with ripened coryza?
New, unripe coryza is calmed with ghee prepared by dosha; ripened coryza with thick phlegm is drained by nasal medication.
To bring it to ripeness the text uses sudation, massage, gargles with the three pungents and emesis, and ripening foods such as warm dry-ginger water, milk with red shigru and fresh ginger, pulse soups and a sour horse-gram gruel with pepper. Vitiated coryza gets ghee with alkaline and pungent drugs, strong nasal drops, warm affusion, smoking and plasters.
Study questionHow does the text treat pitta-type and kapha-type heart disease?
Pitta type: emesis with drugs mixed with ghee, jaggery and milk, then purgation. Kapha type: emesis with warm water containing trikatu, then purgation with trivrit, sour fruit, rock salt and dry ginger.
Verse 7 adds that the pitta treatment described earlier may also be used, and verse 9 adds enemas with drugs suited to the dosha.
Study questionWhich foods does the text tell a worm patient to avoid?
Curd, jaggery, sugarcane juice, fruits such as mango, all kinds of milk, meat, sweet tastes and food or drink containing leafy vegetables.
Verse 22 lists these as unwholesome; verse 20 adds that meals of pungent and bitter items are very beneficial for worm patients.
Study questionWhat are the three kinds of ajirna, and which dosha does the footnote link to each?
Ama ajirna (food stays raw and sweet) from kapha, vidagdha (food turns sour) from pitta, and vishtabdha (severe pain, distension, retained stool) from vata.
Verse 24 adds that constant eating of many foods, like a cow, causes ajirna, from which alasaka, vilambika and vishuchika arise; verse 29 calls fasting the best measure.
Study questionHow does the text tell vatabasti apart from mutratita?
In vatabasti, vata aggravated by suppressing urine closes the bladder outlet, so urine is retained with pain in the bladder and lower abdomen; in mutratita, urine that was held back will not come when wanted, or comes only a little at a time with straining and pain.
Both belong to the urinary obstruction (mutraghata) group of verses 39 to 52, several of which are traced to holding back the urge to urinate.
Study questionHow many yoni diseases does the editorial note count, and how are they grouped?
Twenty: five each from vata, pitta, kapha and all three doshas.
The note gives the causes as wrong diet and conduct, vitiated menstrual blood, semen defects and fate; verse 75 says the type caused by all three doshas is to be given up as incurable.
Study questionHow does the text distinguish a blood gulma from pregnancy?
Both show the signs of pregnancy, but the limbs of a foetus move without pain, while the gulma throbs as a lump with pain.
The blood gulma occurs only in women, shows pitta signs and is treated like pitta gulma; a footnote says it becomes easily curable when old and is treated after ten months.
Study questionWhat does the text give as the cause of kamala?
Taking much sour and other unwholesome food and conduct soon after fever, burning or pandu have subsided, which aggravates pitta.
The aggravated pitta whitens (or yellows) the body and causes great swelling; the treatment given for swelling is said to help, with a decoction of jaggery, haritaki, cow urine and iron ash and meals of barley and shali rice.
Study questionWhy does the text reject the idea that apasmara is caused by grahas?
It says apasmara comes from quickly moving doshas, so it arrives suddenly and passes quickly; ignorant people take this for a graha's work, but it is born of the doshas.
Verses 112 and 113 describe the attack (falling, gnashing teeth, vomiting phlegm, upturned eyes, loud cries) with vata predominant, and verse 117 treats it with the drugs for insanity and strong nasya.
Study questionHow does the text explain why some diseases appear quickly and others slowly?
By the nature of the diseases, as sown seeds sprout early or late, and by karma from past actions, as ocean waves come one by one or many together.
Verses 115 and 116 make both points; verse 99 adds that no effect arises without internal and external causes.
Study questionHow is the plant glossary वनौषधिशब्दादर्श laid out?
Each numbered entry gives a Sanskrit headword with its gender, then Hindi, Marathi and Kannada equivalents in columns.
The column heads read संस्कृत, हिंदी, मराठी and कन्नड. The entries are arranged by initial letter (अ, आ, इ, उ, ऊ, ए, ऐ, क, ख and ग in this part) and the numbering starts again at 1 in each letter section; some entries only refer to another headword with देखो (Hindi) and पहा (Marathi).
Study questionWhich three items does the glossary list for कटुत्रिक?
सोंठ (dry ginger), मिरच (black pepper) and पीपल (long pepper), together called त्रिकटु.
Entry क 3 glosses कटुत्रिक as त्रिकटु and numbers its members 1 सोंठ, 2 मिरच, 3 पीपल; the Marathi column gives सोंठ, मिरी and पिंपळ. Entry क 2, कटुक, also begins with त्रिकटु, सोंठ, मिरच, पीपल.
Study questionWhich weights and measures are explained in this part of the glossary?
अक्ष (karsha, 2 tolas), कोल (one tola), कुडव (32 tolas), कुची (eight handfuls) and गुंजा (one ratti).
Besides plant names, some headwords are glossed as measures: अक्ष as कर्षपरिमाण, '2 तोले का प्रमाण' (अ 56); कोल as 'एक तोला' (क 86); कुडव as '32 तोला प्रमाण' (क 103); कुची as 'अष्टमुष्टिप्रमाण' (क 59); and गुंजा as '1 रत्तिप्रमाण' (ग 29).
Study questionWhich drugs does the verse under काकोल्यादिगण name?
काकोली, क्षीरकाकोली, जीवक, ऋषभक, ऋद्धि, वृद्धि, मेदा, महामेदा, गुडूची, मुद्गपर्णी, माषपर्णी, पद्मक, वंशलोचन, शृंगी, प्रपौण्डरीक, जीवन्ती, मधुयष्टि and द्राक्षा.
Entry क 43 gives no Hindi or Marathi equivalents; instead it quotes a Sanskrit verse that ends by saying this group is called काकोल्यादि by name.
Study questionAccording to the glossary, what is गूगल?
The gum of the गुग्गुल tree.
Under गुग्गुल (ग 8) the Hindi column says 'गुग्गुल का पेड, इसका गोन्द गूगल है' and also gives शिलाजित and the red सैजिना as senses; the Marathi column lists महिषाक्ष, आरक्तवर्ण, महानील and कुमुद.
Study questionWhat Hindi and Marathi names does the glossary give for अटरूष?
Hindi वासक वृक्ष, अडूसा वृक्ष and बसौंटा; Marathi अडूळसा.
Entry अ 22 gives these names; आटरूष (आ 4) repeats अडूसा with the Marathi अडूलसा, and आमलक (आ 8) also lists बांसा, अडूसा and बसौंटा.
Study questionWhat does the glossary say about कुसुम्भ?
It glosses it as the flowers of कुसुम, with whose colour cloth is dyed.
Entry क 76 (printed कुसंभ, neuter) gives the Hindi 'कुसूम के फूल [जिस के रंग से वस्त्र रंगा जाता है]' and the Marathi कुर्डईचे फूल.
Study questionWhich senses does the glossary give for अग्नि?
चित्रक and लाल चित्रक, भिलावा, नींबू, सोना, केशर and पित्त, among others.
Entry अ 13 lists चित्रकवृक्ष, रक्तचित्रकवृक्ष, भल्लातक, निंबूक, स्वर्ण, केशर and पित्त, with the Hindi चीतावृक्ष, लाल चीता, भिलावे का वृक्ष, नींबू का झाड़ and सोना and the Marathi विस्तव, चित्रक, बिबवा, सोने and निंबू; अग्निद्रुम (अ 15) refers back to it.
Study questionWhy is consumption called kshaya, shosha and rajayakshma?
Kshaya because it wastes the tissues such as rasa, shosha because its heat dries them daily, and rajayakshma because it destroys even kings.
Verse 4 explains the names; the commentary calls them meaningful names of tapedik, and a footnote says even a king is not freed from it.
Study questionWhy is rajayakshma called sannipatic though vata, pitta and kapha types are named?
Because the features of all three doshas appear together and the course of treatment is the same.
The dosha names only reflect which dosha predominates more or less (verse 5).
Study questionHow is the Mahakshayarogantaka ghee matured and taken?
The medicated ghee is mixed with sugar candy, bamboo manna and vidanga decoction, churned, sealed in an earthen pot and kept in a heap of grain for fifteen days; then one pala is licked daily, followed by cow's milk.
The text describes it as sharpening intellect, aphrodisiac and life-promoting, calming consumption and pandu and needing no dietary restriction.
Study questionWhat causes of pox (masurika) does the text name?
The anger of cruel grahas, smelling poisonous flowers, poisoning, irregular eating, disturbed seasons, transgressing religious duties, sacrifices with killing, killing, and harassing or angering monks.
The commentary equates masurika with devi, mata or chechak, and verse 32 links its blisters to past karma.
Study questionHow, according to the text, do pox and some other diseases pass from person to person?
Through touching the patient's body, living near him and eating food he has touched.
Verse 63 names swelling, kushtha, fever, eye diseases and calamity-born pox; before treating such contagious diseases the physician protects himself with mantras (verse 64).
Study questionWhich ways of treating children does the text say expose them to grahas?
Frightening them in many ways (for example with talk of ghosts), beating them repeatedly, terrifying them, and bringing them up in dirty or deserted houses.
Verse 70 adds impure conduct, lack of auspicious things and the mother's faults.
Study questionWhat signs mark a child seized by the Kinnara graha, and how is he treated?
A fixed stare, a smell of blood, a crooked mouth, a twitching eyelid, refusal of the breast, watery eyes and clenched fists; he is treated with fragrant oil massage and baths, fumigation, a herbal garland, and red garlands and offerings.
Study questionWhat kinds of measures make up the treatment of the child grahas?
Baths in herb decoctions, oil massage, medicated ghee to drink, fumigation, herbal amulets and garlands, offerings (bali) and mantras.
Each graha from Kinnara to Rakshasa has its own bath, oil, ghee, fumigation and amulet, and places for the bath and offering are also given, such as a crossroads, a banyan tree, a pond or a cowshed.
Study questionOn which days or times do the different grahas roam, according to verses 127-128?
Devas on the full-moon day, asuras at the twilights, gandharvas on the eighth lunar day, yakshas on the first, ancestral bhutas in the dark fortnight, rakshasas and (per the commentary) pishachas at night, and nagas on the fifth.
Study questionWhat kind of physician should a king keep near him to guard against poison?
One who knows all mantras and the science of poisons, is of good family, free of greed, skilled, righteous and pure in conduct, and has wealth and kinsmen.
Verse 2 says such a physician should be kept in due manner; a footnote explains that defeated enemies, punished men, jealous relatives and women seeking favour may try to poison a king. The physician must also examine cooks and attendants and watch for the signs of a poisoner.
Study questionHow is food tested for poison with an offering and with fire?
Flies and crows that eat a morsel set aside soon die, and in fire poisoned food crackles and gives off unbearable peacock-blue smoke.
Verse 8: one or two morsels are put aside as an offering before eating; if poisoned, flies sitting on them and crows eating them soon die. Thrown into fire, the food crackles, its smoke is peacock-blue and unbearable and its flame breaks up. Verse 19 adds signs shown by birds and deer kept near the kitchen.
Study questionWhat signs show that wine, curd, milk or buttermilk has been poisoned?
Wine and water show black streaks, curd turns white with a slight yellow tinge, and milk and buttermilk show red streaks.
Verses 11-13 add that poisoned liquids in general show strange colours, bubbles and foam, pulse soups show blue streaks, reflections in poisoned liquids look double, distorted or absent, and poisoned dishes soon become tasteless and stale.
Study questionWhat goes into Vishaghna ghrita and how is it given?
Ghee is processed with liquorice, sugar, ativiṣā, indralatā and the three pungents; the poisoned person licks it and is then given a well-flavoured meal.
The commentary says the ghee is prepared with a decoction and paste of these drugs and that it removes the pain of poison; the verse says a king who takes it can eat and drink without fear even if poison (gara) is brought to him.
Study questionWhat are the three kinds of poison, and in which ten parts does immobile poison reside?
Poison is immobile (forest-born), animal or artificial; immobile poison resides in root, leaf, flower, fruit, bark, latex, exudate, heartwood, minerals and tubers.
Verses 30-31 give examples: the roots of kaner and guñjā, the leaves of viṣapatrikā and karambha, the fruit, leaves and flowers of dhatūrā and bitter gourd, the heartwood, exudate and bark of the cilla tree, the latex of arka, tilvaka and snuhī, and orpiment, sulphur, realgar and saṅkhiyā among minerals.
Study questionWhich are the thirteen tuber poisons?
Kālakūṭa, karkaṭaka, sarṣapaka, kardamaka, vatsanābha, mūlaka, puṇḍarīka, mahāviṣa, sambhā (śṛṅgī), mustaka, hālāhala, pālaka and vairāṭaka.
Verses 38-44 give each its own signs; for example kālakūṭa destroys the sense of touch and causes violent trembling, vatsanābha makes the eyes, faeces and urine yellow and stiffens the neck, and hālāhala causes giddiness, laboured breathing and fainting. Verse 45 says these poisons, having the ten qualities, kill quickly.
Study questionWhat are the ten qualities of poison?
Dry, hot, sharp, quick, pervasive, indigestible, light, loosening, subtle and clear.
Verses 47-49 explain their actions: dryness provokes vāta, heat pitta and blood, subtlety spreads poison into the finest parts, sharpness breaks the vital points, pervasiveness fills the body, quickness kills fast, the loosening quality agitates the dhātus and clarity lets it enter them. Verse 76 says animal poisons have the same ten qualities.
Study questionWhat is dūṣīviṣa according to the text?
A poison weakened by age, fire, lightning, sun, frost, rain or antidotes that lingers in the body and later, roused by unsuitable conditions, vitiates the dhātus.
When roused it causes vomiting, loss of appetite, thirst, fever, burning, breathlessness, cough, intermittent fever, swelling, insanity, diarrhoea and abdominal disease, and in its various forms leanness, drying up, hernia or scrotal enlargement, excessive sleep, bloating and loss of semen. The Dūṣīviṣāri agada is given for it.
Study questionHow is poisoning treated in its first and second stages?
In the first, emesis followed by cold water sprinkled on the body or drunk and then an antidote with ghee; in the second, emesis followed by purgation.
Verses 60-62 continue: nasal medicine, collyrium and an antidote drink in the third stage; antidotes without ghee in the fourth; an antidote with a decoction of sweet drugs in the fifth; treatment as for diarrhoea with strong nasal medicine and collyrium in the sixth; and sharp collyrium, pressed nasal medicine and a crow's-foot incision on the head in the seventh.
Study questionInto how many kinds are snakes divided, and what are they?
Five: darvīkara (hooded), maṇḍalī (with round patches), rājīmanta (striped), vaikarañja (born of mixed parentage) and nirviṣa (non-poisonous).
The non-poisonous kind includes snakes of water and the rainy season, parrot-green or moon-white in colour, and the python. Divine serpents carry poison in their sight and breath, for which the commentary says there is no medicine, while earthly snakes bite with their fangs, when protecting their young, in frenzy, from hunger, when trodden on or touched, from fear or anger.
Study questionWhat kinds of snakebite does the text distinguish?
Svarpita, radita (rachita) and udvihita, plus the non-venomous sarpangabhihata swelling from fright.
Svarpita is a bite with one to four venomous fangs, wounds, swelling and intense poison; radita shows red, black or white lines with swelling but no wound and little poison; udvihita shows fang marks without swelling and is non-venomous; sarpangabhihata is swelling from vata provoked by fright at a snake's touch in a timid person, also non-venomous.
Study questionWhich dosha does the poison of each kind of snake provoke?
Darvikara poison provokes vata, mandali poison pitta, rajimanta poison kapha, and vaikaranja poison two doshas.
The text adds that a darvikara bite shows all vata signs, a mandali bite pitta signs such as burning and a rajimanta bite kapha signs, so the physician identifies the snake from the signs and removes the poison with suitable medicines and mantras.
Study questionWhy does snake poison have exactly seven stages (vega), according to the text?
Because the poison, carried by vata, passes from one dhatu to the next, each passage making one stage, and there are seven dhatus.
The commentary says the poison stays at the bite for at most 450 matra units of time (a footnote defines a matra as the time to circle the hand once around the knee and snap the fingers); reaching rasa makes the first stage, passing from rasa to rakta the second, and so on, so there are seven stages, not eight or six.
Study questionWhat first measures does the text describe for a snakebite on a hand or foot?
Tying the limb tightly four finger-breadths above the bite, then cutting out the bitten flesh to let the poisoned blood out.
Where the bite cannot be tied off, the place is cut and burnt with fire, or the poison is sucked out with the mouth filled with earth. A footnote explains that tying keeps the poison from spreading because poison spreads through the blood; the text then adds venesection near the bite or, if the poison has spread, at the hands, feet or forehead. These are procedures for a trained practitioner.
Study questionWhat role does the text give to mantras in snake poisoning?
It says even poisons that medicines cannot remove yield to mantras, so life is first protected with mantras and medicines are applied afterwards.
Mantras also appear with medicines in removing poison once the snake is identified (v92), in the protective use of smeared instruments (v125), and in the treatment of severe insect poisoning together with incision (v147).
Study questionWhy is the Sanjivana antidote so named, and how is it stored?
The text says it revives even a person close to death; it is kept in a horn.
Equal parts of manjishtha, licorice, both drumsticks, turmeric, lac, realgar, orpiment, ingudi, cardamom and renuka are powdered and mixed with the group of urines (the commentary: eight kinds) and the salts (five kinds). The text gives no route or dose, and it contains arsenic minerals, so it belongs to professional practice only.
Study questionHow does the text contrast insect poison with other poisons in treatment?
Other poisons are very hot and sharp and get cooling measures, while insect poison is cold, increases kapha and causes vomiting, and gets hot measures.
For poison in general the text names cold-water bathing and cooling food; for insect poison it names fire sudation, fumigation, hot pastes and poultices, hot food and sudation, saying that insect poison grows with cold treatment.
Study questionWhat is jalatrasa and what does the text say about it?
Fear at the sound, touch or sight of water; after bites of fierce animals it is a fatal sign, and even without a bite it is regarded as one.
The text says people bitten by fierce animals who act like the biting animal, see its form in a mirror, lamp, sunlight or water and suffer jalatrasa show fatal signs and are not to be treated; earlier it says such bitten people, with thirst, bleeding, swelling and vata-kapha poison, become mad and bite others.
Study questionWhat are the signs that a person is free of poison, and what should a poisoned person avoid?
Body heat settles, the senses are clear, appetite returns and excretion is normal; a poisoned person avoids day sleep, sex, much exercise, sun and anger, and oil, horse gram, sesame, liquor, kanji, buttermilk and sour things.
Once free of poison the person is given suitable gruels and drinks. In strong poisons all food goes with cooling measures, but in insect poison hot food, sudation and pastes are used.
Study questionIn what order does chapter 20 say the seven dhatus arise?
Food becomes rasa, then blood, flesh, fat, bone, marrow and semen.
The food and drink a person takes are digested into rasa; from rasa comes blood, from blood flesh, from flesh fat, from fat bone, from bone marrow and from marrow semen. The commentary adds that elements of hot and cold nature and the specific doshas are the chief auxiliary causes of their formation.
Study questionHow does chapter 20 arrive at sixty therapeutic measures, and which four kinds of procedure does it name?
Fifty-three listed measures plus the second forms of seven measures that act both by cleansing and by healing make sixty; the four procedures are cautery, surgery, caustic and medicine.
The commentary lists fifty-three measures, from drying, plastering and affusion to diet and protective rites. Decoction, wick, ghee, oil, paste, rasakriya and dusting powder each have a cleansing and a healing form; one form of each is already counted, so the other seven are added to reach sixty. A footnote says these sixty are meant for wounds. For pacifying all diseases the text names agnikarma, shastrakarma, ksharakarma and aushadhakarma.
Study questionWhat should a patient avoid after oleation, purgation, enemas, bloodletting and the like, and for how long?
For one month: anger, sex, long sitting, much walking or standing, overexertion, loud speech, grief, heavy food, riding, sun, cold water, strong wind, day sleep and other unsuited things.
Verses 8 and 9 add that the patient should take water and food prepared with drugs that pacify his own dosha so that the digestive fire grows. Verses 10 and 11 explain that these eight great procedures weaken the fire, which is rebuilt with a graded series: hot water, boiled-and-cooled water, yavagu, vilepi, yusha, khala and then food with little and with more ghee, each for three, two or one days by grade of weakness.
Study questionWhat are the ten times for taking medicine in chapter 20?
Nirbhakta, pragbhakta, urdhvabhakta, madhyabhakta, antarabhakta, sabhakta, samudga, muhurmuhu, grasa and grasantara.
Nirbhakta is medicine alone in the morning, only for the strong; pragbhakta is before the meal and digests quickly; urdhvabhakta, after the meal, treats the upper body; madhyabhakta, in mid-meal, treats the middle body; antarabhakta, at midday between meals, kindles the fire; sabhakta is medicine cooked into food for those averse to medicine, children, the old, the emaciated and women; samudga, before and after the meal, calms doshas above and below; muhurmuhu is repeated dosing in dyspnoea, hiccup and belching; grasa is powder mixed with a morsel; grasantara is medicine between morsels for cough and dyspnoea.
Study questionHow do the six tastes give sixty-three varieties?
6 single tastes, 15 pairs, 20 combinations of three, 15 of four, 6 of five and 1 of all six make 63.
The commentary counts sweet, sour, salty, pungent, bitter and astringent singly (6), then every pair such as sweet-sour (15), every triple (20), every set of four (15), every set of five (6) and all six together (1). It adds that a physician who knows doshas, tastes and the preliminary, main and after procedures should apply them according to the doshas.
Study questionHow is a decoction made when a ghee recipe gives no rule, and whose opinions does the text cite?
The drug is boiled in four times water down to an eighth according to Shrutakirti and Kumaranandi, or to a sixteenth according to Virasena and other ancient teachers.
Verse 23 gives the decoction rule with these two opinions. Verse 24 then gives Pujyapada's rule for cooking oil and ghee: the decoction reduced to a quarter is cooked with half as much milk, half as much fat and drug paste a quarter of the fat until only the fat remains. Verse 25 accepts all the teachers' differing views and names three grades of cooking: mild, sticky and hard-sticky.
Study questionWhich dreams does chapter 20 treat as signs of death in particular diseases, and which dreams does it call fruitless?
Many red things for raktapitta, yellow for pandu, white for kapha and reddish for vata patients, and befriending a monkey for a wasting patient; dreams that follow one's nature, habit or repeated thoughts are fruitless.
Verse 35 says such patients surely die when they see these dreams. Verse 36 adds that evil, demon-like dreams bring many diseases to a healthy person and death to a patient, while verse 37 calls dreams of the five supreme beings, one's guru, a king, Jina temples, friends, crossing water or riding a fine horse or elephant auspicious.
Study questionHow many marmas does chapter 20 count, and how are they grouped by outcome?
107: 19 immediately fatal, 29 fatal after an interval, 3 fatal when the dart is removed, 48 disabling and 8 pain-causing.
By region the text counts 44 in the four limbs (11 each), 12 in the abdomen and chest, 14 in the back and 37 from the throat to the head. By structure they are bone, ligament, joint, vessel and flesh marmas. Those wounded at a marma are said mostly to die of the pain within a fortnight, and survivors live maimed or with damaged senses.
Study questionWhat does the text say happens when a dart lodged in the utkshepaka or sthapani marma is pulled out?
The person dies at once; he lives while the dart stays in, or if it falls out by itself after suppuration.
Utkshepaka lies at the hairline above the shankha marmas and sthapani between the eyebrows. Because withdrawing the dart kills, they are classed as vishalyaghna marmas, of which verse 81 counts three.
Study questionWho was Ugraditya's teacher, where was the Kalyanakaraka composed, and which teachers does it name for the limbs of Ayurveda?
Shrinandi Acharya; at Ramagiri in Kalinga; Pujyapada (shalakya), Patrakesari (surgery), Siddhasena (toxicology and graha pacification), Dasharatha (internal medicine), Meghanada (paediatrics) and Simhanada (aphrodisiacs and rejuvenation).
Verse 86 adds that Samantabhadra expounded all eight limbs at length and that Ugraditya presents them in brief. A footnote traces eight-limbed Ayurveda to the Pranavada Purva within the Drishtivada, the twelfth limb of the Jain canon, calling it the root text on which all teachers drew.
Study questionWhat four kinds of therapeutic action does chapter 21 name?
Caustic (kshara), fire (agni), knife (shastra) and medicine (aushadha).
The text says one well-performed procedure can cure a disease, while some diseases need two, harder ones three and the hardest all four; complications follow from neglected aftercare, the patient's conduct or the physician's ignorance.
Study questionWhat are the two kinds of kshara by use, and where is each used?
Pratisaraniya kshara, applied externally, and paniya kshara, which is drunk.
External kshara is listed for kushtha, tumours, sinus tracts, fistula-in-ano, external worms and poisons, mouth and tongue disorders and rohini; potable kshara for gara poison, udara, gulma, weak digestion, stone and gravel, piles, internal poisons and worms, breathlessness, cough and severe indigestion.
Study questionWhy does the text rank cauterisation above caustic therapy?
Because diseases burnt with fire are destroyed from the root and do not recur, and diseases that kshara, medicine or knife cannot cure yield to it.
Even so, fire is not applied to ligaments, bones and joints, and it is avoided in summer and autumn unless an urgent disease requires it, in which case counter-seasonal cooling measures are taken first.
Study questionWhat are the four kinds of accidental burns, and how is a bad burn treated?
Sprishta, samyag-dagdha, durdagdha and atidagdha; a bad burn is sprinkled with lukewarm milk, smeared with ghee and cooling pastes, and its blisters are opened and covered with cool leaves.
A touched burn is warmed with fire and given warm pastes, an even burn gets ghee and cooling pastes of sandalwood, sesame, liquorice and rice, and an over-burn needs strongly cooling care, removal of hanging tissue, washing with milk and wound treatment.
Study questionWhich means of bloodletting do some teachers match to each dosha?
A horn for blood vitiated by vata, leeches for pitta and a gourd with fire in it for kapha.
Others say no such order is needed and any suitable means may be used for any dosha; a footnote explains that a lamp is kept inside the gourd, otherwise it draws no blood.
Study questionHow many kinds of leeches does the text describe, and which one is not used on people?
Twelve, six poisonous and six non-poisonous; the savarika is used only for animals such as elephants and horses.
The poisonous ones are krishna, karbura, alagarda, indrayudha, samudrika and gochandana, whose bites cause swelling, blisters, burning, fever, vomiting and fainting; the non-poisonous are kapila, pingala, shankhamukhi, mushika, pundarikamukhi and savarika.
Study questionHow can one tell that a leech has begun to draw pure blood, and what is done then?
The bite becomes very painful and itchy; rock salt is put on the leech's mouth to detach it at once.
After it drops off, the leech is dusted with rice powder, given rock salt and oil on its mouth and pressed from tail to mouth to vomit, while the bite is washed with cold water and sprinkled with milk or ghee, and heavy bleeding is stopped with styptic powders.
Study questionWhat harm does the text say comes from letting too much blood from a vein?
Vata disorders, wasting, breathlessness, cough, hiccup, anaemia, insanity, heat in the head and even quick death.
So even vitiated blood is not let in excess and what remains is pacified with shamana medicines; if bleeding becomes excessive it is stopped and boiled, cooled cow's milk is given daily with a little cooling, digestion-kindling food.
Study questionWhich instrument does the text assign to each surgical action?
Vriddhipatra for cutting and scraping, utpalapatra for splitting, kutharika for piercing bone, vrihimukha for piercing flesh, patrika for letting out fluid and eshani for probing.
The physician has these made by skilled smiths, gathers medicines, instruments, an operating room, hot and cold water, fire and gentle attendants before operating, and uses instruments such as the kankamukha to extract foreign bodies.
Study questionHow does one know that the ghee drunk for oleation has been digested?
The body feels light, appetite returns, the mind is clear, speech, urine, stool and flatus move properly, belching is clean and the senses are clear.
Verse 5 gives these signs. If the ghee is not digested, verse 4 says it produces anorexia, fever, prameha, insanity, kushtha and fainting, and the patient is given hot water with rock salt or made to vomit with lukewarm water.
Study questionFor how long is ghee or sesame oil drunk for oleation, and why not longer?
For three, five or seven days with the amount raised step by step; after that it becomes habituated (satmya), so it is not drunk beyond seven days.
Verse 7 sets this limit. Verse 10 adds that the right amount is the one that digests by midday without causing mada, fatigue, languor, burning, fainting or loss of appetite.
Study questionWhat are the signs of excessive oleation and how is it treated?
Burning at the anus, excessive stools, anorexia, kapha from the mouth, dysentery, burning of the limbs and fainting; it is treated with dry ginger in hot water and rice with mung soup, or a gruel with ajamoda, chitraka and rock salt.
Verses 18 and 19 give the signs and remedies. By contrast, verse 17 names the signs of proper oleation: oily stools, aversion to ghee and food, and languor of the limbs.
Study questionWhat are the four kinds of sweating described, and what is each said to suit?
Heat (tapa), steam (ushma), poultice (bandhana or upanaha) and liquid (drava) sweating; tapa and ushma chiefly pacify kapha, the poultice destroys vata, and liquid sweating suits vata or kapha mixed with raktapitta.
Verses 23 to 25 define each kind. The commentary adds that sweating helps only an oleated body, so it follows oil massage; on a dry body it burns.
Study questionWhat does the text say happens when sweating is overdone, and what is done about it?
It aggravates pitta and blood and quickly causes blisters, giddiness, mada, fever, burning and fainting; very cooling measures are applied.
Verse 28 gives this. Verse 29 then has the patient troubled by cold water drops bathed with warm water and, once his fire is kindled, fed light, liquid, fire-kindling food; the editor prefers the reading प्राणातिपात (a life-threatening state) there.
Study questionWhy should purgation be given only after emesis?
Because purgation is especially beneficial for one already given emesis; if purgation is given without emesis, kapha goes down, spreads through the abdomen and covers the digestive fire, and many diseases soon follow.
Verse 42 states this order, and verse 43 describes the small, light, warm, unctuous meal and the sour hot-water drink given the day before purgation.
Study questionHow is the dose of a purgative matched to the kind of bowel?
A soft bowel (from pitta) gets a mild dose, a hard bowel (from vata and kapha) a sharp dose and a medium bowel (balanced doshas) a medium dose.
Verses 44 and 45 give the three kinds of bowel and their doses; verse 52 adds that where the bowel's nature is unknown, a gentle, mild purifier is used.
Study questionWhich complications of emesis and purgation does the text list?
Fifteen: the emetic going down or the purgative going up, residual medicine, digested medicine, scanty removal, excessive removal, vata colic, jivadana, ayoga, atiyoga, parisrava, parivartika (parikartika), hridaya-sanchara, vibandha, adhmana and atipravahana.
Verses 53 and 54 list them, and the commentary says they arise from negligence or ignorance of the physician, patient or attendant; only the first pair is specific to one procedure.
Study questionHow does the text tell life-blood (jivashonita) from raktapitta?
Blood smeared on a cloth that keeps its colour after washing with hot water, and that a dog eats when it is mixed with sattu, is life-blood; otherwise it is raktapitta.
The test is given in verse 75 and its commentary. Jivadana, the discharge of life-giving blood after purification, is treated with cooling measures and cold drugs that stop the blood (verse 76).
Study questionWhat is parisrava after purgation, and how does the text say it arises?
A long, painful discharge of pitta and kapha in small stools, which the text says follows a too small or mild purgative given to a person with a dry, hard bowel and many doshas.
The weak purgative only stirs the doshas up, bringing weakness, loss of taste, fatigue and obstruction. The text treats it with stopping drugs, stopping asthapana enemas and a small meal of warm rice with ajamoda, shatapushpa, ghee and milk.
Study questionWhich complications of emesis take the place of parikartika, parisrava and pravahika of purgation?
Throat soreness (galakshati), dripping of kapha (kaphapraseka) and dry belching.
The text says this completes the fifteen complications each of emesis and purgation; the editor's footnote explains that parikartika and parisrava cannot occur in emesis, so emesis is given its own counterparts.
Study questionWhat does the text prescribe when the enema nozzle has tilted downward during application?
An asthapana enema of milk, decoction of milky-sap trees and licorice, followed by an anuvasana enema of ghee.
A downward-tilted nozzle lets the fluid fall too far and quickly burn the receptacle; the text then gives these two enemas.
Study questionWhat happens when an enema is pressed too hard, and how is it handled?
The fluid comes out through the mouth and nostrils; it is checked at once, sharp head and body purgatives are given, cold water is sprinkled and the fluid is brought down.
The commentary mentions rubbing and shaking the throat as the immediate measure. Too gentle or repeated pressing, by contrast, lets wind in and causes distension, which is met with a vata-destroying enema.
Study questionWhat is jivadana according to the text, and how is it treated?
The excessive flow of life-blood when the atiyoga of an enema increases; it is treated by the method given for atiyoga of purgation.
The text attributes the name to the Jinas. Atiyoga itself is said to follow a very sharp enema given suddenly to a person with few doshas, a soft bowel or a well-sweated body, and is calmed with an enema of licorice, milk and ghee.
Study questionWhy must an anuvasana enema not be given on an empty stomach?
On an empty bowel the oil rises upward and causes faults, so the patient is first fed suitable food and the enema is given while his hand is still wet.
The text also gives the oil's measure as half the niruha fluid, and says the enema causes fever if given after burnt food, and harm if given after very unctuous food or to an uncleansed body.
Study questionWhat effects does the text attribute to the first ten oil enemas of a series?
The first oils the groin, the second removes vata from the whole body, the third gives lustre, colour and strength, the fourth to seventh oil rasa, blood, flesh and fat, the eighth and ninth bone and marrow, and the tenth calms disorders of semen.
A person given niruha is accordingly to receive nine or eighteen oil enemas; the text further says that 324 oil enemas make one godlike and long-lived for a thousand years, which is reported as a traditional statement.
Study questionWhat signs show that a niruha enema has been given properly?
The fluid, stool, pitta, kapha and vata come out in order, the disease subsides and the body feels light.
For both oil and niruha enemas the text adds subsidence of the disease treated, cleansing of wastes and contentment of the senses, self and mind; a proper oil enema returns with vata and stool.
Study questionFor whom is the jaggery-and-oil (gudatailika) enema meant, and how is it made?
For kings, wealthy men, the very old, children, delicate persons and women who cannot bear the usual enemas; jaggery and oil in equal measure are combined with castor-root decoction.
The text says no restriction of food, drink, sleep, sitting or sexual activity is needed during its use, and the footnote counts the yuktaratha, colic-destroying and siddha enemas that follow as its varieties, since all contain jaggery and oil.
Study questionWhat is the uttarabasti, and what fluid measures does the commentary give for it?
A footnote defines it as the basti given into the male organ, or into the urinary passage and uterus of women, named so because it is given after the niruha. It is oily or of decoction: the fat is one pala (four tola) for men, half a pala for women and a quarter pala for girls under twelve, and the decoction one prasrita for all; to cleanse the uterus both are doubled.
Its nozzle is said to have the shape of the stalk of a jasmine (malati) flower. A footnote says prasrita here means as much fluid as fills the patient's palm from the roots of the fingers, not two pala. It is given three or four times according to the strength of the disease, and the chapter calls it the chief means of removing the defects of semen and menstrual blood.
Study questionHow does the text judge the curability of disorders of semen and menstrual blood?
Disorders from vata, pitta or kapha singly are curable and are overcome with oleation, sudation and similar procedures; the corpse-smelling, pus-like, foul and knotted kinds are difficult to cure; the faeces-smelling kind is called incurable.
Seed vitiated by blood smells like a corpse, by kapha and vata becomes knotted, by pitta and blood becomes foul and pus-like, by all three doshas smells of faeces, and excessive intercourse depletes it. Medicated ghees are given for the corpse-smelling, knotted and pus-like kinds, and verse 13 still gives a ghee of trikatu, triphala, agnimantha, lotus and musta for the faeces-smelling kind.
Study questionWhat are the signs of pure semen and of pure menstrual blood in chapter 23?
Pure semen is very unctuous, fragrant and sweet, like crystal, honey or sesame oil; pure menstrual blood is red like liquid realgar, hamsapadi paste, hare's blood, lac juice or bright saffron, and washes out of a cloth without staining it.
The commentary says excellent offspring come only from such semen and that offspring arise from such artava. With predominance of pure artava a girl is conceived, with predominance of semen a boy and with their equality a napumsaka, all following the predominant karma of the past.
Study questionWhat are the five kinds of medicated smoke, and how long is the smoking pipe for them?
Oleating, prayogika, emetic, purgative and cough-relieving smoke. The pipe is 48 angulas long for the prayogika smoke, 32 for the oleating smoke and 16 for the purgative and cough-relieving smokes.
The bore should let an urad grain pass. The oleating and prayogika smokes are drawn through mouth and nose, the purgative smoke through the nose and the emetic and cough-relieving smokes through the mouth only, and smoke is always let out through the mouth. The prayogika smoke is used until tears come to the eyes, the others until the doshas come out; excessive smoking is said to cause ringing in the ears, headache, weak sight, loss of taste, burning and thirst.
Study questionHow do gandusha and kavala differ, and how full should the mouth be for a gargle?
Gandusha is holding a liquid in the mouth, while kavala also involves holding and chewing dry drugs. The gargle liquid should fill half the mouth, because a full mouth cannot move the liquid about and so does not remove all the doshas.
The liquid is held still until the medicine is enveloped in kapha and spat out when the eyes fill with water and the nose runs; it is repeated with fresh liquid until the doshas come out, head heaviness goes and hoarseness and other mouth diseases calm, and no more is held, since excess causes drying of the throat, thirst and other complications. Liquids of the alkali, sour, oil, ghee, urine and astringent groups are chosen according to the dosha.
Study questionWhat are the two basic kinds of nasya, and at which nine times is pratimarsha given?
Oleating (snehana) nasya and head-purging (shirovirechana) nasya. Pratimarsha, a kind of oleating nasya, is given on rising, on going out, after cleaning the teeth, after day sleep, after walking, after passing urine, after vomiting, after meals and in the evening.
For oleating (marsha) nasya eight drops of lukewarm oil go into each nostril, sixteen drops being the first dose, the second double and the third double again. The head-purging liquid is given four drops in each nostril as the lightest dose, doubled for the middle and again for the best dose. The measure of pratimarsha is as much fat as, put into the nose, reaches the mouth. A footnote names avapidana (juice) and pradhamana (blown powder) as kinds of purging nasya.
Study questionWhat are the three stages of an inflammatory swelling, and how is each treated?
Unripe (ama): hard, slightly painful, of healthy skin colour, slightly warm and cold; it is calmed with dosha-pacifying pastes. Burning (vidagdha): severe pain, great heat, discolouration, tension like an inflated bag, thirst and aversion to food; it is ripened with poultices of strong ripening drugs. Ripe (pakva): pain calmed, soft, pale, itching, pus moving under pressure; it is pressed, opened, cleansed and bandaged.
Swelling turns towards ripening when the doshas are very strong, the treatment is wrong or none is given. A deep kapha swelling may be ripe without showing all the signs; its cool touch and healthy skin colour show that it is ripe. Bandages are loose at the joints and eyes, medium at the face, limbs, ears, throat, genitals, back, flanks and chest, and tight at the buttocks, head, thighs, groins, pelvis, abdomen and armpits.
Study questionWhom does the text call an ignorant physician in the treatment of swelling?
One who out of ignorance cuts open an unripe swelling thinking it fully ripe, or neglects a fully ripe one thinking it unripe; both are called ignorant and great sinners, and a wise patient should leave them.
Only the physician who knows the unripe, burning and ripe stages well is called the best of physicians. The text also warns that a deep-seated kapha swelling can mislead the physician, because it may be ripe without showing all the signs of ripeness.
Study questionHow is the great aksha (bibhitaki) oil used, and what does the text say it does?
A person afflicted by grey hair, wrinkles and old age is first purified by emesis, purgation and the like, then given nasya of the oil with great care in a windless house, repeatedly for a month.
The oil is one adhaka of bibhitaki oil cooked with a paste of many flowers, herbs and minerals, one tola each, made with decoctions of asana, khadira heartwood and triphala and kept ten days in an iron pot. The text says the nasya removes nose diseases (in the commentary), makes the face like a lotus and even the old youthful, and that the oil should be given to loved ones; these are the text's traditional statements.
Study questionWhat do the hair-blackening preparations of verses 88 to 101 have in common?
Every one of them contains iron powder, most also triphala and several nilanjana, bhringaraja, nili and sesame oil; most are matured in an iron vessel or a treated pot, often buried in a heap of grain, then worshipped and applied to the hair.
The mango-kernel paste is matured four months and the mango-iron-jujube paste six; the haritaki paste six, three, two or one month; the shyamadi paste ten nights and its oil a month; the preparation with copper, iron, nilanjana and bronze powders four months. Several are applied after a triphala paste and wash, some are also taken as nasya, and one is drunk as well. The text says white hair turns black, often at once; these are traditional statements.
Study questionWhat are the three processes of mercury named at the start of chapter 24, and what result does the text give for each?
Murcchana (swooning), marana (killing, making bhasma) and bandhana (binding): swooned mercury destroys many bad diseases, killed mercury brings wealth, grain and enjoyment, and bound (siddha) mercury gives the power of moving through the sky and freedom from ageing and death.
The text calls mercury rasaraja and says it yields much wealth through processes such as jarana with mica and other metals. These results are the text's traditional statements; it also says that only properly bound mercury is rasayana.
Study questionWith what does the text say mercury is swooned and killed, and how is the killed mercury taken?
It is swooned by grinding with old jaggery and killed with wood-apple juice, or quickly with gobandhana, sticky palasha-seed juice, cumin or kuchi seeds; the killed mercury, rubbed with gold, is taken daily in well-boiled milk with jaggery according to the measure of the doshas.
Afterwards a nasya of woman's milk is given and the body is massaged by women's hands. The text says the mercury then pervades the body, that rubbing with gold gives more vigour and freedom from disease, and that a rasayana regimen is followed daily with it.
Study questionWhy does the text set out a faultless method of binding mercury, and what must come before the work begins?
Because mercury processed with other metal groups containing rasa is not to be eaten: the text says it gives rise to kushtha and many other diseases, while properly bound mercury is rasayana.
The physician must know the texts on binding and have chief attendants, equipment, wealth and devotion to the guru. A very secret workshop is built at an auspicious time and in an auspicious direction, the Jina, the yakshas, Ambika and Kushmandini are worshipped, the namokara mantra is recited 24 times, and a preliminary initiation is taken with the nine planets.
Study questionHow is mercury purified (shodhana) in this chapter?
It is ground in a stone mortar with brick powder and milk and washed with kanji, then tied in a bundle with trikatu, kanji, salts and asafoetida, steamed for three days in a kanji-filled vessel through a dolayantra, and washed with lukewarm kanji.
The text says the purified mercury, like a demon, eats and digests all metals; the commentary adds that gold put into it mixes at once, its weight does not increase, and the gold cannot be separated again. A quarter part of red bija (gold) is then added and digested by garbhadruti between layers of vida.
Study questionHow do the editor's footnotes define bija, garbhadruti and vida?
Bija is a metal that, put into another metal while it is being cooked, gives it its own colour, and pure gold and silver are also called bija; garbhadruti is making what mercury has swallowed liquid inside the mercury; vida is the mixture of alkalis, sour substances, sulphur, cow urine, salts and the like used to digest what mercury has swallowed.
Each footnote supports its definition with a quoted Sanskrit verse. In verse 16 itself the vida is impregnated with the three alkalis, trikatu, the salt group and the sour group.
Study questionWhat quality does the text say each process gives to mercury?
Svedana makes it intense, mardana free of impurities, processing with metals strong, jirna pure, bandhana siddha, garbhadravana blended into one, ranjana coloured, and sarana able to pervade the body.
These are called the eight great processes; mercury bound by them is said to be pure like the siddhas, like a living being and godlike, with the powers beginning with anima. Sarana, pratisarana and anusarana are said to make it a hundred, a thousand and a hundred thousand times stronger.
Study questionHow does the text make mercury stay steady in fire?
It is put in the juice of sarpakshi, sharavarini, sahachari, patha and kakadani and steamed with oil combined with their paste and decoction; it then stays steady even in very sharp fire.
The commentary names the plants sarahati-gandani, sarpata, yellow katasaraiya, patha and kakadini. Earlier, in rasabrimhana, the mercury is also made fire-resistant by grinding salt, orpiment, earth and husk, coating the mercury with mica paste and heating it at the mouth of a dry fire.
Study questionHow is the siddha ghee-nectar (siddhaghritamrita) made?
One pala of ghee, two pala of mercury and four pala of milk are cooked in an iron vessel on a mild husk fire until the milk is consumed and only ghee remains.
The text says it becomes like nectar, worthy of worship even by the gods. Just before it, a ghee of bound mercury with triphala-water ghee and two haritaki, drunk daily, is said to make a man as strong as a rutting elephant, and one pala of gold bhasma mixed into that ghee may be used as nasya.
Study questionWhat is the lamp (dipana) process described near the end of the chapter?
Lamp vessels are smeared with lac juice and the sulphur and poison groups ground in breast milk; mercury mixed with gold bhasma, tied in a fine cloth, is placed in the vessel, and the lamp is lit with karanja and sesame oil.
It follows the instruction to take a little of the tested perfected mercury with a quarter part of gold bhasma, which the dipana process helps to digest quickly. The text says the smearing makes the mercury very bright and more powerful, and the commentary that perfected mercury changes every dhatu of the body.
Study questionWith what does the text say mercury is made to pass into metals (sankramana)?
With the juices of five plants (the commentary: musta, palasha, gorakhmundi, betel and milky-sap trees), and, for the perfected king of mercury, with beeswax mixed with svarnamakshika, crow dung, nalika, buffalo ear-wax, woman's milk, the paravati tree, meshashringi and borax powder.
In the first method mercury mixed with the plant pastes is smeared on leaves and applied to a mirror, which it is said to pervade by itself. In the second, the verse also names man's blood, which the commentary does not list.
Study questionIn chapter 25, what is haritaki taken with to remove vata, pitta and kapha?
With salts such as rock salt for vata, with ghee for pitta and with dry ginger for kapha.
Verse 3 says abhaya with salts destroys aggravated vata and with ghee removes severe pitta; verse 4 adds that with dry ginger it removes kapha, with costus it destroys the diseases of all doshas, and with sugar it removes the complications of disease.
Study questionWhich fruits make up triphala, and why does the commentary call the name apt?
Haritaki, bibhitaki and amalaki; the commentary says they remove the disorders arising from the three doshas.
Verse 6 says bibhitaki has qualities like abhaya, as the Jina taught, so the three together are called triphala. Verses 7-8 praise triphala as nectar on earth that removes all diseases, keeps youth, firms the body, gives intellect, cleanses the wastes and kindles the fire.
Study questionHow does the text say shilajatu arises, and which metals are named as its sources?
In summer the sun-scorched mountains exude a red juice like lac from their cracked rocks; tin, lead, iron, copper, silver and gold are named as its six sources.
Verse 21 compares the flow to the ichor of a rutting elephant. Verse 22 says shilajatu from each later metal in the list has more virtue, and a footnote explains that the metals in mountain rock melt in the heat and take the form of shilajatu. It is taken with triphala decoction, milk and ghee in great disorders of kapha, pitta and vata.
Study questionHow does the physician make sure the vamyesha used in its kalpa is not poisonous?
He takes only vamyesha that birds have eaten, since, as the footnote explains, birds do not eat the poisonous kind.
In verse 24 a physician who knows poisons chooses it after considering whether it is poisonous; it is given with milk, ghee and sugar, the diet is rice with ghee and milk, and vegetables, sour things and leafy greens are avoided. The commentary glosses vamyesha as kavach seed or talmakhana.
Study questionWhere is the bhallataka stone said to be found, and how does the footnote define adhaka and drona?
Three kos east of the famous city of Kolipaka, near a village of the same name; four ser make one adhaka (a ser being sixty-four tola) and four adhakas make one drona.
In verses 26-28 one adhaka each of the stone powder, cow ghee, bhallataka oil and jaggery is cooked with four adhakas of bhallataka root decoction into one drona of linctus, which is licked daily in a set measure with a diet of shali rice, ghee and milk.
Study questionHow are the vajras processed in the vajra kalpa before they are taken?
They are burnt red hot in a bellows fire, quenched in water of patala and arjuna wood ash, washed seven times with very hot horse-gram decoction, put into milk and powdered; the powder is licked with ghee and sugar.
Verses 33-34 list the kinds of vajra as vajra, vajraloha, vajrabandha fruit, vajrakapala and vajra stone. The footnotes add that the quenching is done seven times and that they are also heated and quenched in milk seven times, and an editor's footnote prefers reading abhisheka as heating and quenching rather than washing. Verse 35 has the vajra rasayana taken with ghee for six months.
Study questionHow is the alkaline water of the kshara kalpa turned into the finished medicine?
The alkaline water is cooked down to a quarter, a quarter part of jaggery is added and it is cooked to the consistency of phanita, a quarter part of trikatu, trijata and nagaramotha powder is mixed in, and it is kept in a prepared pot buried in grain for a month.
In verses 41-42 the ash of talmakhana, sugarcane, musli, tilaja, apamarga, nirgundi, rambha, arka, lotus, castor, chitraka, sesame and other drugs is stirred into four times its water and strained to give the alkaline water. A footnote defines phanita as sugarcane juice cooked until slightly thick yet still liquid. Taken by rule, the text says it overcomes even incurable great diseases.
Study questionAgainst which diseases is the chitraka rasayana said to work, and how is chitraka root purified?
It is said to destroy strong rajayakshma (kshaya), dreadful piles and all diseases; the footnote says the root is purified by keeping it in lime water.
In verses 43-44 the decoction of the purified root is mixed with sugar, burnt shankhanabhi, phanita and the paste of all the fragrant drugs, kept for a month in a pot buried in grain, and then drunk constantly by rule.
Study questionAccording to the author's closing verses, who was his guru, and from what source and in what language did he compose the Kalyanakaraka?
His guru was the great muni Shrinandi, honoured by King Vishnuraja; by his command Ugradityacharya condensed the work from the great Pranavaya canon in Ardhamagadhi and composed it in Sanskrit.
Verse 52 gives the purpose: to accomplish the gift of medicines and to fulfil the austerity of affection toward good physicians. Verse 53 says the uttaratantra was first taught by the Jinas, and the commentary on verse 56 counts 2583 great verses in the work.
Study questionWhat comparison does the text use for protecting the body with medicines?
As a king protects his city from enemies with his army and weapons, a person should protect the body from the enemy of disease with medicines.
Verse 49 adds that one who ignores the medicines and conduct taught here lets the body, the abode of dharma and happiness, be spoiled by the doshas and perish; verse 50 says that with a healthy body gained through medicine, practising dharma well brings the aims of life in the next birth.
Study questionWhat does the rishta appendix call rishta, and to whom should approaching death be announced?
Whatever signs appear that are wholly contrary to a person's own earlier nature and disposition are called rishta by the Jinas. Death should never be announced to people gripped by fear of old age, disease and death who know nothing of other lives, but should certainly be told to those who, frightened by wandering through the four states of existence, seek liberation.
The commentary says that the news can terrify the fearful so that diseases arise and they die before their time, and that a very timid person may give up life at once; those seeking liberation should in turn hear the signs of their own time of death gladly. The signs are said to appear in people who still seem healthy.
Study questionWhich signs does the rishta appendix give for death within one year and within six months?
Within a year: seeing a circular halo in the half moon and being unable to see the pole star, the star Arundhati, the sky, the moon's rays or the day's sunshine. Within six months: owls, crows, fierce vultures and similar birds flying over a person's head or forcibly sitting on it.
The list runs from two years (seeing the discs of the moon and sun and the earth in the five colours of a rainbow or as if full of holes) down to one day (not hearing the samudraghosha, which a footnote explains as the sound heard when the ears are closed with the fingers, and not seeing the light at the corner of the eye or the tip of the nose). These are the text's traditional prognostic statements.
Study questionHow does the text match parts of the body that a person can no longer see with the time left to live?
Foot three years, shank two years, knee one year, thigh ten months, waist seven months, belly four months, neck one month, hand fifteen days, arm eight days, shoulder three days, and chest, head and his own shadow two days.
Knowing this, the wise man is to give up his possessions and take initiation (diksha). The next verse adds signs of the senses: deformed eyebrows nine days, a sound like the samudraghosha in the ears seven days, a deformed nose five or four days, disordered light of the eyes three days and a deformed sense of taste one day, after which sallekhana is to be taken up.
Study questionWhat should a seeker of liberation do when fatal signs appear, according to the rishta appendix?
He should leave home, vehicles, family and all possessions and go north or east to a large, pure, quiet place free of creatures, such as a place of pilgrimage, a Jina temple, a garden or a forest, worship and meditate there and, wishing for samadhi-marana, take up sallekhana when the time draws near.
Seated facing east or north on clean ground, a rock or sand, he first worships the guardian of the place, then the Jinas and the twenty-four Tirthankaras, practises dharmya and shukla meditation as his strength allows and contemplates the five-fold salutation. The appendix closes by urging the best of sages to keep the mind firm, reflect on birth, old age, death and the impermanence of the body, and go forward in the austerity that leads to liberation.
Study questionHow does the hitahita chapter argue that no substance is wholesome or unwholesome in every respect?
It rejects the one-sided view that water, ghee, milk and rice are absolutely wholesome and fire, alkali and poison absolutely unwholesome: if the former were wholesome everywhere and always, people with new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye disease or wounds would have to take them constantly, while alkali, fire, instruments and poison used by skilled physicians relieve diseases at once.
Its examples include poison treating poison, fire treating burns, the excision and burning of a bite and bloodletting with sharp instruments. Arguing from syadvada, it concludes that because things are many-sided, all things are incompatible or compatible according to substance, place, time and state, and that the first medical science is that of the Arhat.
Study questionWhat does the hitahita chapter, quoting Sushruta, say about substance, taste, potency and vipaka?
There is no vipaka without potency, no potency without taste and no taste without substance; substance is the most important, because taste, potency and vipaka depend on it, and the eight qualities called potency rest in substance, not in the tastes.
The wise are said to accept the combined action of all four: a substance acts on a dosha by itself, through its potency, or through its taste and vipaka, and substance and taste arise in mutual dependence, like body and embodied soul. The text uses these quotations to say that Sushruta too relies on syadvada.
Study questionOn what grounds does the hitahita chapter say that meat is neither food, nor medicine, nor rasayana?
Not food: Brahma and the others did not eat it, nourishment runs from milk to food, children are first given light food with milk at six months, and meat is very incompatible with milk. Not medicine: it is absent from the lists of drugs, it neither purifies nor, having no distinct taste of its own, pacifies, and no dose and none of the ten times for medicine is given for it. Not rasayana: it is absent from the rasayana section.
The text also argues that eaten meat does not add to the flesh as flesh, since the body grows through the sequence of rasa and the other dhatus, that many people who eat no meat are stout and strong while some meat-eaters are thin and weak, and that the meat passages of other medical texts were added later by meat-loving authors. These are the chapter's own arguments, reported as written.
Study questionWhich food combinations with milk does the hitahita chapter warn against?
Milk taken with meat, fish, jaggery, black gram or modaka sweets is said to bring on kushtha, and taken with vegetables, jambu fruit, sura or asava to kill the ignorant quickly like a snake; meat and milk together are called unworldly, unpleasant and excluded by the texts.
A quoted verse also lists plain meat, old women, the rising sun, freshly set curd, intercourse at dawn and sleep at dawn as six things that take life at once. The milks of eight animals (goat, camel, cow, sheep, buffalo, horse, elephant and deer) and the urines of eight are named as those used in medicine, never those of flesh-eaters.
Study questionWho should treat holy men, and with what medicines, according to the end of the hitahita discussion?
The physician of holy men should himself be a holy man; failing one, a Jain layman; failing that, even one of wrong faith; and failing that, even a wicked physician of wrong faith won over with honour, gifts, trust, mantras, medicines and knowledge. They are to be treated with pure, fresh, fragrant, nourishing medicines well freed of life (prasuka), or, when these cannot be had, with sinless medicines chosen with care.
Holy men must be protected in every way and their comfort alone thought of. Medicine brought with compassion after worshipping the trees is called meritorious, the root being taken from the north side and leaves, flowers and fruits from the other sides, without destroying the plant. The text records that this discourse against meat was proclaimed by Ugradityacharya in the assembly of Maharajadhiraja Nripatunga Vallabha.
Study questionWhy does the Hindi rendering of the hitahita chapter hold that no substance is wholesome or unwholesome in every respect?
Because by substance, place, time and state things have many-sided natures; if water, ghee, milk and food were wholesome in every way, they would have to be used even in new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye diseases and wounds.
Arguing from syadvada, the translation rejects the one-sided view that water, ghee, milk and food are absolutely wholesome and fire, alkali and poison absolutely unwholesome. The 'wholesome' things would then have to be given even in new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye diseases and wounds, while poison, alkali and fire are themselves used to treat some diseases, poison being said to destroy poison.
Study questionBy which four procedures, according to the translation, are diseases treated, and why should none of them be relied on alone?
Poison, alkali, fire and instruments; some diseases are treated by one of them, some by two, some by three and some by all four.
Whoever calls fire, poison or alkali wholly wholesome or wholly unwholesome is said to contradict the very treatment that prescribes them. In the treatment of poison, sucking out the poison of the wound, cutting and burning are called useful everywhere, and a wound that cannot be ligated is burned with a slight fire; when poisoned blood is let out with sharp instruments, the signs of proper letting are given as lightness of the body, lessening of the force of the disease and cheerfulness of mind.
Study questionWhich combinations with milk does the translation say cause kushtha or quick death?
Milk taken with meat, fish, jaggery or sweets made of black gram is said to cause kushtha, and milk used with liquor made from vegetables and jambu fruit is said to kill the fool quickly.
These statements support the argument that meat is very incompatible with milk. The translation adds that all medicines are said to become potent only when used with milk, except honey, ghee, pippali and vidanga, and that this rule about milk was given to exclude meat.
Study questionWhat is health said to be the means of, and what does a person without it fail to achieve?
Health is said to be the means of dharma, artha, kama and moksha; without it a person, however steadfast and brave, cannot practise dharma, earn wealth, enjoy pleasures or reach liberation.
Medical science is said to be taken up for health, which is marked by balanced dhatus and the like, lustre, energy and strength; when the four aims are lost the person's very existence is said to be lost, and the sick cannot even study the science of health. The closing section adds that the muni who studies this science secures health, the cause of the bliss of liberation, and that holy men can keep to their path of restraint only with a body free of disease.
Study questionOn what grounds does the translation say that meat is not a medicine?
It is not taken up in the sections on collecting medicinal substances, is neither purifying nor pacifying, has no taste of its own, and has no time or measure of use laid down for it.
Meat lacks the power to purify upward, downward or both ways, and having no particular taste of its own it cannot pacify doshas as the tastes do. None of the ten times for taking medicine is fixed for it, and no measure is given for it as for liquids, fats, powders and pastes. It is not read in the rasayana chapter and is opposed to milk. The closing argument concludes that meat is not food, nor a well-known medicine, nor an excellent rasayana, and that honey, liquor and meat were mixed into the science later by people greedy of the tongue.
Study questionWhich eight kinds of milk does the translation say are effective in medicine?
The milk of the goat, sheep, cow, buffalo, mare, she-elephant, she-donkey and she-camel.
A second quoted list gives the eight as goat's, camel's, cow's, buffalo's, sheep's, horse's, elephant's and deer's milk. The meat, milk, dung and urine of meat-eating animals are left aside, and only the dung, urine and milk of grass-eating animals are taken in medicines; the closing argument accepts milk, ghee, curd and buttermilk from animals because they arise from causes of comfort such as the animals' nourishment, touch and the suckling of calves.
Study questionHow does the translation answer the doubt that plant medicines are also meat because they are bodies of living beings?
Meat is the body of a living being, but a living body need not be meat, just as a neem is a tree but not every tree is a neem.
Where the pervaded (vyapya) is present the pervader (vyapaka) is present too, but not the reverse, as with shinshapa and tree. Just as woman is a name common to sister and wife yet one is approached and the other not, food (anna) and meat, though alike bodies of living beings, are one to be eaten and the other not. Grains, pulses, roots, fruits, flowers and leaves are described as fit for the worship of the gods and pure, and a physician devoted to true dharma cannot call them meat without contradicting perception, his own words, scripture and the world.
Study questionHow should plant medicine be collected, according to the Paitamaha quoted in the translation?
The root of a tree that has gone toward the north is brought after worshipping it, and the leaves, fruits and flowers bent toward the east, south and west are taken.
Plant medicine taken with compassion, after worship, to treat the twice-born, holy men and munis is said to be a cause only of merit, the slight sin of work done for merit being compared to a particle of poison that cannot spoil an ocean of cool nectar. The rule is said to be for the favour of living beings, so the trees are not to be destroyed from the root.
Study questionWho should treat holy men, and with what medicines, according to the translation?
Holy men devoted to yoga, with pure, life-free medicines; failing such a physician, a lay follower (shravaka); and failing him, a physician of wrong faith won over with honour, gifts and respect.
The first choice of medicine is the fragrant substances of perfumers' shops, from distant islands, of many tastes, potencies and vipakas, life-free, fresh, clean and nourishing; failing these, suitable medicines grown in कृष्ण regions, turned up by the ploughshare and not too dry, collected in any season as available; failing these, pure life-free medicines chosen with care, as the Kalpa-vyavahara says. Holy men are to be protected in every way, since only with a healthy body can they keep to their path of restraint.
Study questionWhy does the closing section say that even munis should study Ayurveda?
Because the muni who studies it secures health, the cause of the bliss of liberation, while one who does not, afflicted by diseases born of his own doshas, is bound by karma through the evil states of his mind.
Under the heading आयुर्वेदाधययनफल the translation concludes that the study of Ayurveda is necessary even for munis, and adds that whoever studies, salutes and praises this great science spoken by Ugradityacharya gains a brilliance like the sun. Just before, it records that the discourse against meat was proclaimed in the assembly of King Nripatunga Vallabha, where this Jain physician proved before meat-favouring scholars of Ayurveda that meat is fruitless.
Study questionWhich three triphalas does the Marathi column list under त्रिफला?
The common triphala (हरडे, बेहेडे, आंबळकटी), a fragrant triphala (जायफळ, सुपारी, लवंग) and a sweet triphala (द्राक्षा, दाडिम, खजूर).
Entry त 37 (त्रिफला, feminine) gives the Hindi हरड, बहेडा, आमला. The Marathi column continues with सुगंधत्रिफळा followed by जायफळ, सुपारी, लवंग, and मधुर त्रिफला followed by द्राक्षा, दाडीम, खजूर.
Study questionWhich salts does the glossary list under पञ्चलवण?
In Hindi कचिया, सैंधा, समुद्र, बिरिया संचर and काला नोन; in Marathi लवण, टंकण, सैंधव, औद्भिद and संचळ.
Entry प 39 (पंचलवण, neuter) lists five Hindi salt names ending in नोन. The Marathi column gives a partly different set, which includes टंकण (borax) and औद्भिद (printed अैद्धिद).
Study questionWhat three items make up त्रिजातक according to the glossary?
दालचीनी, इलायची and तेजपात (Marathi दालचिनी, तमालपत्र, एलची).
Entry त 36 (त्रिजातक, neuter) gives these three in both columns. The neighbouring entries त 34 त्रिकटु and त 40 त्र्यूषण both give सोंठ, मिरच, पीपल, and the Marathi of त्र्यूषण ends with the word त्रिकटु.
Study questionWhich weights are named in this part of the glossary?
धान्य as a weight of four sesame seeds, पिचु and बदर as two tolas, and माणिका as 64 tolas.
Entry ध 4 (धान्य) gives 'चार तिल परिणाम' and the Marathi 'चार तीळभार वजन'; प 23 (पिचु) gives 'दो तोले परिमाण'; ब 2 (बदर) gives '2 तोले'; and म 30 (माणकी) prints '[माणिका]-64 तोले'.
Study questionWhat senses does the glossary give for नाग?
Tin, lead, नागकेशर, the पुन्नाग tree, मोथा, पान, poison, बचनाग, अभ्रक, नागबला, मेदा and ivory, among others.
Entry न 7 (नाग, masculine) has the Hindi रांग, सीसा, नागकेशर, पुन्नाग का वृक्ष, मोथा, पान and a long Marathi list: सिसें, विष, बचनाग, ऊर्ध्ववायु, पानवेल, कथील, नागकेशर, रक्तवर्ण, अभ्रक, नागर, नागबला, मेदा, हस्तिदन्त, नागवल्ली, सुरपुन्नाग and नागरमोथा.
Study questionHow does the glossary explain तरली?
As a यवागू made of barley flour, as liquor and कांजी, and as the honeybee.
Entry त 4 (तरली, also तरला, feminine) gives the Hindi 'यवागू [जै के आटे का बनता है] मदिरा, मधुमक्खी' and the Marathi कांजी, मद्य.
Study questionWhat do मधुक and मधूक mean in the glossary?
Both mean licorice (मुलहटी, ज्येष्ठीमध) and the mahua tree (महुआ, मोहाचा वृक्ष); मधुक is also glossed as tin, honey and wax.
Entry म 8 (मधुक) has the Hindi मुलहटी, रांग and the Marathi मोहाचा वृक्ष, गोडें कोष्ठ, कथील, मध, ज्येष्ठीमध, मेण; entry म 12 (मधूक) has मुलहटी, महुआ वृक्ष and ज्येष्ठीमध, मोहाचा वृक्ष.
Study questionWhich entries in this part only refer to another headword?
नागीदल (to नागी), नृपद्रुम, नृपवृक्ष and नृपाङ्घ्रिप (to नृपतरु), बिम्बिका (to बिम्बी), भ्रमर (to भृङ्ग) and मदनफल (to मदन); पूतिकरंज refers to पूतिक in its Hindi column only.
Such entries write देखो X in the Hindi column and पहा X in the Marathi column. In पूतिकरंज (प 37) the Hindi says देखो पूतिक while the Marathi gives घाणेरा करंज, and in नृपांघ्रिप (न 33) the Hindi prints नृपेतरु for नृपतरु.
Study questionHow does the glossary describe यवागू?
As a thin rice preparation (पातळ भात) made by adding six times as much water as rice.
Entry य 3 (printed यवागु [गू], feminine) only repeats यवागू in the Hindi column. The Marathi column gives घनसिक्था, पातळ भात and 'तांदुळांचे साहापट पाणी घालून करावा तो', that which is made by adding six times as much water as rice.
Study questionWhich senses does the glossary give for माष?
उड़द (black gram), a weight whose size differs between authorities, and the disease मशक.
Entry म 35 (printed माष [षा]) lists उडद and then the weight: 5 ratti according to Magadha and Sushruta, 10 ratti according to the vaidyaka and 12 ratti according to the Jyotisha-smriti, with further figures for Charaka and the Kalinga measure that are partly garbled in the conversion. The Marathi column gives उडीद, रोग and पंचगुंजात्मक मापमान, a measure of five gunja.
Study questionWhat does the glossary give for व्योष?
सोंठ, मिरच and पीपल, that is त्रिकटु, the three pungents.
Entry व 53 (neuter), the last of the व section, lists सोंठ, मिरच and पीपल in the Hindi column and त्रिकटु in the Marathi column.
Study questionWhat does the entry सुरेन्द्रकाष्ठ say?
It only refers the reader to सुरदारु (देखो सुरदारु, पहा सुरदारु), which the glossary glosses as देवदारु.
Entry स 32 (neuter) has no Hindi or Marathi words of its own. Entry स 30, सुरदारु, gives देवदारु in the Hindi column and तेल्या देवदार, देवदार and सरल देवदार in the Marathi column.
Study questionWhat is सूत in the glossary?
Mercury: पारद in the Hindi column and पारा in the Marathi column.
Entry स 36 (masculine) glosses सूत as पारद and पारा. The numbering then goes straight on to स 38, सूरण (जमीकन्द); no entry 37 is printed.
Study questionWhat do हरीतक and हरीतकी mean in the glossary, and how many kinds of हरीतकी does it mention?
Both are हरड़ (Marathi हिरडा), and the Marathi column under हरीतकी says that हिरडा is of seven kinds.
Entry ह 6, हरीतक (neuter), gives हरड in Hindi and हरितक शाक and हिरडा in Marathi. Entry ह 7, हरीतकी (feminine), gives हरड, हर्र and हड in Hindi and adds in Marathi 'हिरडा सात प्रकाराची आहे'; the seven kinds are not named.
Study questionWhich senses does the glossary give for क्षीर, and which entries after it gather milky plants?
Milk and the gum of the सरल tree in the Hindi column, and water, milk, बकाण निंब, the milk of a cow that has just calved, खीर and a kind of incense in the Marathi column. क्षीरद्रुम, क्षीरी, क्षीरिका and क्षीरिणी then list milky trees and plants.
Entry क्ष 5 (neuter) is printed ़ीर. क्षीरद्रुम (क्ष 6) is the पीपल tree, with the bracketed addition 'गूलर and other milky trees', and क्षीरी, क्षीरिका and क्षीरिणी (क्ष 8–10) list many such plants, among them खिरनी, सेहुंड, आक, बड़, गूलर, पिंड खजूर, वंशलोचन and क्षीरकाकोली.
Study questionWith which entry does the plant glossary end, and how does the book close?
With क्ष 12, क्षुरक (तालमखाना, गोखरू); the book then closes with the line इति भद्रं भूयात्।
The last letter section is क्ष (heading printed -़ा-), with 12 entries from क्षणदा (हलदी) to क्षुरक. क्षुरक lists तिलकपुष्प वृक्ष, तालमखाना, गोखरू and भूतराज in Hindi and कोळिस्ता, तिलकपुष्प, बोरू, गोखरू and नाकसिंकणी in Marathi. The closing line इति भद्रं भूयात् means 'thus, may there be well-being'.
Study questionWhich letter sections does the last part of the plant glossary cover?
The end of म (from entry 31, मातुलुंग), then य, र, ल, व, श, ष, स, ह and क्ष.
On PDF 748–765 the numbering restarts at 1 in each section: य has 8 entries, र 18, ल 14, व 53, श 55, ष only 2 (षट्फल and षष्टिक), स is numbered to 48 with no entry 37 printed, ह has 15 and क्ष 12. The म entries 31–59 complete a section that begins earlier in the glossary.