Skip to content

Principleसिद्धांत

Wholesome diet and conduct (pathya)

पथ्य

Extracted from the text5 references

Built from passages of the source by the curated extraction. Pending human review.

Names and synonyms

Sanskrit
पथ्यहित
Hindi
पथ्यहितकर आहार
English
Wholesome diet and conductwholesome dietpathyarecommended diet
Romanized
pathya

What the text says

Each statement reports the source, with its chapter, page and verse. Traditional descriptions are not presented as proven medical facts.

Classification2

  • Stating the opposing position, the text reports that some teachers hold no substance to be wholly wholesome or unwholesome, because what is wholesome for vata is unwholesome for pitta; the one-sided view answers that substances, by nature and by combination, are either absolutely wholesome, such as water, ghee, milk and cooked rice, being naturally suited, or absolutely unwholesome, such as fire, alkali and poison, which burn, cook and kill, while others become like poison when combined.

    Appendix: Hitahita · p. 608Sanskrit verseTraditional description
  • The translation sets out the opposing view: some Jain teachers say no substance is one-sidedly wholesome or unwholesome, since what is wholesome for vata is unwholesome for pitta; the one-sided view answers that water, ghee, milk and food (anna) are absolutely wholesome, that fire, alkali and poison, which burn, cook and kill, are absolutely unwholesome, and that other substances become poison-like by combination.

    Appendix: Hitahita · p. 623Hindi commentaryTraditional description

Diet1

  • Every grain should be used after carefully examining the person's constitution, region, season, disease and so on, choosing what suits them.

    Chapter 4 · p. 53 · v. 24Hindi commentaryTraditional description

Cautions1

  • The merits and faults of these grains should be weighed before using them, otherwise harm follows.

    Chapter 4 · p. 53 · v. 25Hindi commentaryTraditional description

Other3

  • The author replies that absolute must mean in every respect: if water, ghee, milk, rice and the like were wholesome everywhere, always and in every way, they would be wholesome even for people suffering from new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye disease or wounds, who would then have to take them constantly; so the one-sided view does not hold.

    Appendix: Hitahita · p. 608Sanskrit verseTraditional description
  • The reply is that if wholesome substances were wholesome in every way, their use would have to count as wholesome even in new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye diseases, wounds and other severe diseases, and they would have to be used whether suitable or not.

    Appendix: Hitahita · p. 623Hindi commentaryTraditional description
  • The specially learned earlier teachers, who knew both worldly and supreme (paramarthika) matters, are said to have taught the accomplishment of one's duty in the world as attaining the wholesome and avoiding the unwholesome (hitahita prapti and parihara).

    Appendix: Hitahita · p. 635Hindi commentaryTraditional description

Where else is this mentioned?

Named 21 times on 20 pages. These are automatic name matches, so a few may refer to something else with the same name.

Questions and answers

Which foods does the text call wholesome in long-standing diarrhoea and chronic fever?

Buttermilk with rock salt and dry ginger; mung soup with cumin tempered with ghee, salt and black pepper; and milk prepared with ajamoda and rock salt.

Detailed answer and sources
What are the signs that a person is free of poison, and what should a poisoned person avoid?

Body heat settles, the senses are clear, appetite returns and excretion is normal; a poisoned person avoids day sleep, sex, much exercise, sun and anger, and oil, horse gram, sesame, liquor, kanji, buttermilk and sour things.

Detailed answer and sources
How does the hitahita chapter argue that no substance is wholesome or unwholesome in every respect?

It rejects the one-sided view that water, ghee, milk and rice are absolutely wholesome and fire, alkali and poison absolutely unwholesome: if the former were wholesome everywhere and always, people with new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye disease or wounds would have to take them constantly, while alkali, fire, instruments and poison used by skilled physicians relieve diseases at once.

Detailed answer and sources
Why does the Hindi rendering of the hitahita chapter hold that no substance is wholesome or unwholesome in every respect?

Because by substance, place, time and state things have many-sided natures; if water, ghee, milk and food were wholesome in every way, they would have to be used even in new fever, diarrhoea, kushtha, fistula-in-ano, eye diseases and wounds.

Detailed answer and sources

All references

Every page and verse of the source that this entry draws on.

Extraction notes

  • The second एकान्तहितानि in the opposing view is read as एकान्ताहितानि (absolutely unwholesome), as the examples fire, alkali and poison require.

Quick facts

Content type
Principle
Categories
Diet
Source pages with records
4
Pages naming it
20
Extraction tasks
T03, T29, T30
Record id
concept_pathya